F 234 
_p,7 H53 

Copy ^ 



of 
iElp Arltngt0n (EnnM^ratr fEottum^nt 



BY 



?i|tlary A. i^prbprt 

Chairman of the Exeaiti've Committee oj the 

Arlington Confederate Monument 

Association 



Copyright by 

United Daughters of the Confederacy 

1914 






/ 

>CI.A390035 



NOV to m 



v-^ t 



PREFACE. 

When one considers what it is and what it stands for, there 
is no object in or near Washington City better worth a visit 
and a careful study than the Confederate Monument in the 
National Cemetery at Arlington. This booklet is intended to 
give concisely the data from which such a study can be made, 
not only by those wdio are'; fortunate enough themselves to see 
the monument, but by those also who must rely on descriptive 
statements and pictures. 

In its origin and in itself this memorial is entirely without a 
parallel in history. Its story has been here carefully told, and 
every effort has been made in the narrative to do justice to all 
the organizations that have co-operated patriotically in the pro- 
duction of the monument. For its full significance the writer 
relies much on the carefully prepared address of President 
Taft, welcoming the U. D. C. in 1912 to the National Capital; 
that of Mrs. McClurg in reply; that of Mrs. Stevens, the 
President-General of the U. D. C, when she presented the 
memorial to the President of the United States in 1914, and 
that of President Wilson in reply. These speeches are here 
given in full, as are also all the addresses delivered at the 
laying of the corner-stone and at the unveiling of the monu- 
ment. Each presents a separate study of the meaning 
of the monument made from a separate angle. The two 
women, whose addresses are given, Mrs. Stevens and Mrs. 
McClurg, are representative Southerners. President Taft and 
President Wilson in their speeches are at their best. Mr. 
Bryan's address at the laying of the corner-stone was from 
the standpoint of a statesman. The Master of Ceremonies 
and Corporal Tanner, who spoke on that occasion, had fought 
each other at the Second Manassas where Mr. Tanner lost 
both legs. The representatives of the Union and Confederate 
armies, General Bennett H. Young and General Washington 
Gardner, who spoke at the unveiling, made carefully prepared 
speeches that stand for the best sentiment of their respective 



IV 

organizations, and Col. Robert E. Lee's eloquent speech was 
like an echo from his noble grandfather, many of whose noted 
sayings he repeated and emphasized. To carefully read all 
these speeches will be to appreciate the blessings of Ameri- 
can institutions, and to understand how a grandson of General 
Lee could say at the unveiling, "There is no firmer founda- 
tion for the hopes of the Nation than this monument at 
Arlington." 

Chapter I is largely a reproduction of the story of the monu- 
ment given by the author to the public as a prospectus of the 
unveiling. 

Chapter II is an attempt to picture as a body the United 
Daughters of the Confederacy who, with. the loving co-opera- 
tion of Veterans and Sons of Veterans, built and presented the 
monument to the Nation. 

The monument -itself is a group of 33 figures, pedestal and 
all in bronze. Chapter V contains four pictures of it, one 
each from the South, North, East and West, together with an 
effort by the author to explain; the figures composing the mon- 
ument. 

Three full months have now passed since the monument was 
unveiled, and so (far as is known it has been universally com- 
mended. It is perhaps not too much to hope that in the great 
future, when art lovers have become familiar with it, the Con- 
federate Monument in the National Cemetery at Arlington 
will rank among the famous art works of the world. 

Hilary A. Herbert. 
Washington, D. C, October, 1914. 



Arlington (Ennf^Jifratr iUnnnmrnt Aaaoriattun 

DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA ORGANIZATION. 

December, 1906. 

President* Mrs. Magnus S. Thompson 

First Vice-President Col. Hilary A. Herbert 

Second Vice-President 

Recording Secretary Mrs. Drury C. Ludlow 

Corresponding Secretary Miss Mary Desha 

Treasurer Rev. Dr. Randolph H. McKim 

Executive Board: 
Col. Hilary A. Herbert. Hon. Francis M. Cockrell. 

Hon. Seth Shepard. Hon. Charj.es J. Faulkner. 

Rev. Dr. R. H. McKim. Capt. John M. Hickey. 

Gen. Frank C. Arm.stpong ^Deceased). 

Members: 

Seven, each, from Camp 171, U. C. V.; Sons of Veterans, Dist. 
Col. ; Stonewall Jackson Chapter, U. D. C. ; R. E. Lee Chapter, 
U. D. C. ; Southern Cross Chapter, U. D. C. ; Albert Sidney 
Johnston Chapter, U. D. C. 

ARLINGTON CONFEDERATE MONUMENT ASSOCIATION, 

U. D. C. Organization, November, 1907. 

Membership, 1914. 

Mrs. Daisy McLaurin Stevens, President-General, 
U. D. C, President ex-ofUcio. 



*In January, 1907, Mrs. Ralph Walsh, being newly elected Presi- 
dent D. C. U. D. C, became ex-ofUcio President, vice Mrs. Thomp- 
son, retiring D. C. President U. D. C. 



VI 

DIRECTORS. 

Alabama — Mrs. Clifford A. Lanier. 
Arizona — Miss Salome Townsend. 
Arkansas — Mrs. Clementine Boles. 
California — Miss Bessie Topp. 
Colorado— Mrs. J. A. Lovell. 
Florida — Mrs. John W. Tench. 
Georgia — Mrs. James A. Rounsaville. 
Illinois— Mrs. John Willis Heatfield. 
Indiana — Mrs. James T. Cabiness. 
Kentucky — Miss Caby M. Froman. 
Louisiana — Miss Doriska Gautreaux. 
Maryland — Mrs. Frank G. Odenheimer. 
Mexico— Mrs. J. R. Stamford. 
Minnesota— Mrs. Helen G. M. Paul. 
Mississippi — Mrs. Lillie F. Worthington. 
Missouri — Mrs. James Britton Gantt. 
Montana — Mrs. Georgia Young. 
Nebraska — Mrs. Elijah Conklin. 
New Mexico — Mrs. Jo Cato. 
New York — Mrs. Chas. B. Goldsborough. 
North Carolina — Mrs. I. W. Faison. 
Ohio— Mrs. Mary E. Wiltberger. 
Oklahoma — Mrs. Ruth Clement. 
Oregon — Mrs. Nannie Duff Silva. 
Pennsylvania — Mrs. T. Ashby Blythe. 
South Carolina— Mrs. Thos. W. Keitt. 
Tennessee — Mrs. J. W. Clapp. 
Texas— Mrs. J. B. Dibrell. 
Utah — Mrs. Ada Atkins Schooling. 
Virginia — Mrs. Thos. S. Bocock. 
Washington — Mrs. Marie B. Sayre. 
West Virginia — Mrs. Ben Davis. 

The following served terms as Directors, several of them with 
great zeal and efficiency : 

Alabama, Mrs. Chappell Cory; California, Mrs. F. D. Johnston, 
Mrs. W. N. Perry; Colorado, Mrs. A. J. Emerson; Illinois, Mrs. 
G. J. Grommet; Louisiana, Mrs. I). A.. S. Vaught, Mrs. George B. 
Dermody; Minnesota, Mrs. Frank L. Burnett; Mississippi, Miss. 
Olivia H. Champion; New Mexico, Mrs. Robert Bradley; New York, 
Mrs. John J. Crawford; Pennsylvania. Mrs. Charles R. Robinson; 
West Virginia, Miss Charlotte Lee Wilson, Mrs. John Davis Green- 
wade, Mrs. Dudlev, Mrs. Walter C. Pollock. 



Vll 



EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE A. C. M. ASSOCIATION, U. D. C. 

*Col. Hilary A. Herbert, Chairjttan. 
*Mrs. Marion Butler, Vice-Chairman. 
*Mr. Wallace Streater, Treasurer. 
*Mrs. Driiry Conway Ludlow, Rcc. Secretary. 
Mrs. Wm. Oscar Roome, Cor. Secretary. 

*Hon. Seth Shepard. Miss Mary R. Wilcox. 

*Capt. John M. Hickey. Mrs. Jennie L. Munroe. 

Mr. Abner H. Ferguson. Mrs. Leonard G. Hoffman. 

*Mrs. Magnus S. Thompson. Mrs. Marcus J. Wright. 

Mrs. Rust Smith. Mrs. Lindley L. Lomax. 

*Mrs. Jas. E. Mulcare. Mrs. Wm. Anthony Wayne. 

*Mrs. Archibald Young. Miss Fannie W. Weeks. 

Mrs. B. Claughton West. Mr. F. R. Fravel. 

Those marked * have served continuously from the beginning. 

ADVISORY BOARD, A. C. M. ASSOCIATION. 

*Rev. Dr. Randolph H. McKim. ^General Francis M. Cockrell. 

*Hon. Chas. J. Faulkner. *Hon. J. J. Darlington. 

*Hon. Seth Shepard. *Gen. Marcus J. Wright. 

*Dr. Thomas Nelson Page, L.L.D. *Mr. J. T. Callaghan 
Hon. Thomas Caffey. Dr. thos. M. Owen, LL.D. 

Those marked * have served continuously from the beginning. 
J. H. Britt served a term on the Executive Committee, resigned. 

Chapters sometimes rotated representatives. The following 
served terms on the Executive Committee : 

Mrs. R. H. Bocock. Mrs. Helen B. Kendig. 

Mrs. William Youngblood. Mrs. C. C. Calhoun. 

Miss Mary Desha (Deceased). Mr. J. M. Britt. 

Mrs. A. E. Johnson. Mr. Geo. S. Covington. 

Mrs. Mattie Ashley Birney. 

COMMITTEE ON DESIGN. 

Appointed November, 1909. 

Chainnaii, Mrs. Cornelia Branch Stone. 

Rev. Randolph H. McKim, D.D., LL.D. 
Mrs. Marion Butler. 

Hon. Seth Shepard, Chief Justice Court of Appeals, Dist. Col. 
*Col. Hilary A. Herbert. 
Mrs. Thos. W. Keitt. 
Mr. Wallace Streater. 

^Appointed by Mrs. McSherry, who, on her election as President- 
General, resigned her place on the Board to make the vacancy. 

COMMITTEE ON PUBLICATION. ^ 
Miss Mary R. Wilcox, Chairman. 
Mrs. James E. Mulcare. 
Mrs. Rust Smith. 





MRS. DAISY MCLAURIN STEVENS, PRESIDENT-GENERAL U. D. C. 




MRS. CORNELIA BRANCH STONE 

PR ESI DENT- GENERAL 1907-9 

AND 

CHAIRMAN OF COMMITTEE ON DESIGN 





MRS.ViRGINlA FAULKNER M<^5HERRY 

PRESIDENT-GENERAL 1909-11 



MRS. ALEXANDERS. WHITE 

PRESIDENT-GENERAL 1911-13 




M155 SALOME TOWNSEND 
ARIZONA 





MR5.J.A.L0VELL 

COLORADO 




MRS. JAS.TCABINE5S MRS. JOHN W. TENCH MRS.CLEMENTINE BOLES 

INDIANA FLORIDA ARKANSAS 





MRS. JOHN WILLIS HEATFI ELD MRS.CABYM.FROMAN 

ILLINOIS KENTUCKY 




DIRECTORS. 





MI55DORISKAGAUTREAUX 

LOUISIANA 



MRS. HELEN G.M.PAUL 

MINNESOTA 




MRSELiJAHCONKUN MRS JAMES BRinONGANTT. MRS. FRANK G.ODENHEIMER 

NEBRASKA MISSOURI MARYLAND 





MRS.GE0RG1A YOUNG 
MONTANA 



MRS.I.W.FAI50N 
NORTH CAROLINA 



DIRECTORS. 




MRS. NANNY DUFF SUVA 
OREGON 



MRSIASHBYBLYTHE 

PENNSYLVANIA 



MRS.J.B.DIBRELL 
TEXAS 




MR5.TH0S.W.KEITT 
SOUTH CAROUNA 



MRS.ADA ATKINS SCHOOLING 

UTAH 



DIRECTORS. 





MRS. CLIFFORD A.LANIER 
ALABAMA 



MRS. JAMES A.ROUNSAVILLE 

GEORGIA 




MRS.J.W.CUPP 

TENNESSEE 



MRSCHASB-GOLDSBOROUGH 

NEW YORK 



MRSTH0SS.BOCOCK 

VIRGINIA 





MRS.BEN DAVIS 

WEST VIRGINIA 



MRS. MARIE B.SAYRE 

WASHINGTON 



DIRECTORS. 




MISS BESSIE TOPP 

DIRECTOR. CALIFORNIA 




MRS. MARION BUTLER 

VICE-CHAIRMAN 




MRS. JO CATO 

DIRECTOR, NEW MEXICO 




M R 5. DRURY CONWAY LUDLOW 

RECORDING SECRETARY 




MRS.WILLIAM OSCAR ROONIE 

CORRESPONDING SECRETARY 



MR. WALLACE 5TREATER 

TREASURER, A.C.M. A. 




M. EZEKIEL, SCULPTOR. 




SOUTH FRONT. 



CPIAPTER I. 

A CoNFEDERATIi MONUMENT IN A NATIONAL CeMETERY, 

AND Why. 
"But monuments themselves memorials need." — Crabbe. 

The Washington Monument, to an untutored savage, would 
be a stupendous pile — and nothing more. To him who is versed 
in history, especially if he be an American, it is the noblest 
structure in the Universe. Its towering height, its noble pro- 
portions, its strength, its symmetry, these tell the story of 
Washington's life — of the Revolution, of which Washington 
was the soul — of our Federal Constitution, over the framing 
and adoption of which Washington was the presiding genius — 
of the first eight years of our Government under the new 
Constitution, through the perils of which Washington safely 
guided it — of Washington's Farewell Address, in which his 
memorable appeal for the perpetuity of the Union showed 
how anxious and fearful he was lest that new Constitution 
of government might not be able to hold the States together. 
This is the story the Washington Monument recalls to every 
intelligent American who visits the Capital of his country. 

Within plain sight of the Washington Monument, on a hill 
across the Potomac, at Arlington, there stands today another 
monument, and the tale it tells will be no less thrilling and no 
less interesting to future generations than is the story of 
George Washington ; it tells the story of how great the people 
grew to be for whom Washington spent his life — of how 
fiercely they fought each other over the disputed cjuestion that 
had been bequeathed to them by their ancestors, who could 
not themselves settle it, and how, out of their fratricidal war, 
that was the most desperate the world has ever §een, there 
emerged a completed nationality that Washington and others 
of the fathers had wrought for, and prayed for, but had never 
lived to see. 

This monument, standing in the National Cemetery at 
Arlington, takes up the story of our country where the Wash- 
ington Monument leaves ofl^ ; its unveiling was epochal. The 



first speaker was Gen. Bennett Young, Commander of the 
United Confederate Veterans; the next, Gen. Washington 
Gardner, Commander-in-Chief of the Grand Army of the Re- 
public, foUowed by Col. Robert E. Lee, grandson of the great 
Confederate General. Then Col. Hilary A. Herbert, as Chair- 
man of the Executive Committee of the Arlington Confederate 
Monument Association, presented the monument to Mrs. Daisy 
McLaurin Stevens, President of the United Daughters of the 
Confederacy. She turned it over to the President of the 
United States who received it for the United States. 

The Constitution. 
Gladstone, a great Englishman, said in an article entitled 
"Kin beyond the Sea," North American Reviczv, Sept., 1878, 
"The American Constitution is, so far as I can see, the most 
wonderful work ever struck off at a given time by the brain 
and purpose of man." But wise as that Constitution was, this 
is the view of it taken by the fathers, according to an authorita- 
tive American historian, Henry Cabot Lodge : 

"When the Constitution was adopted by the votes of 
States in popular conventions, it is safe to say there was 
not a man in the country, from Washington and Hamil- 
ton, on the one side, to George Clinton and George Ma- 
son on the other, who regarded the new system as any- 
thing but an experiment, entered into by the States and 
from which each and every State had the right to zvith- 
draiv, a right which was z'cry likely to be exercised." 

What caused the fathers of the Constitution to regard it as 
an experiment was their inability to settle in it the question 
whether a state could withdraw from the Union. 

The material progress of the country under that Constitution 
was so amazing as to cause Charles Darwin, who accounted for 
the progress of all animated creatures by his theory of natural 
selection, to say, in his Descent of Man : 

"There is apparently much truth in the belief that the 
wonderful progress of the United States, as well as the 
character of the people, are the result of natural selection; 
for the more energetic, restless, and courageous men from 
all parts of Europe have emigrated during the last ten 
or twelve generations to that great country, and have there 



succeeded best. Looking to the distant future, I do not 
think that the Rev. Mr. Zincke takes an exaggerated view 
when he says : 'All other series of events — as that which 
resulted in the culture of mind in Greece, and that which 
resulted in the empire of Rome — only appear to have 
purpose and value when viewed in connection with, or 
rather as subsidiary to * * * the great stream of 
Anglo-Saxon emigration to the west." 

Secession. 

With the wonderful growth of our country in material pros- 
perity and prestige and power, love of the Union, at the North, 
ripened, until people there forgot the beliefs of their fathers, 
and came to look upon the Union as indissoluble, and upon 
secession as a crime. This the fathers had hoped would be 
universal. 

But a long controversy over slavery had checked the growth 
of Union sentiment in the South, and in 1860-1861 eleven 
Southern States, adhering to the beliefs of the fathers, seceded 
from the Union, set up the old Constitution, amended so as to 
express what they believed the fathers meant, and sought to 
maintain it in a separate government. Issue was joined, Con- 
federates and Federals were fighting for the preservation of the 
same constitution — one side, under a government at Rich- 
mond, the other, under the old government at Washington. 
The people who, Darwin said, had broken the world's record 
in progress, were now to make a zvorld's record in war. 

War. 

The war that followed was a death-grapple — a question, not 
of courage, but of endurance, of superior numbers and re- 
sources, and was fought out for four long years, and decided, 
not on one, oi on a hundred, but on a thousand battlefields. 
It was the bloodiest war in history. Captain Battine, an Eng- 
lish expert, in the "Crisis of the Confederacy," 1905, writing 
after the Russo-Japanese war, says : 

"The American soldier" — speaking of Federals and 
Confederates — "still holds the zvorld's record for hard 
Ughting." 



^ 



Restoration in England. 
Oliver Cromwell died in 1759, and then came the Restora- 
tion. The Royalists exhumed his body, hanged it on a gibbet 
and stuck his head up on a pole. What had been done for his 
bones, malignity and ignorance did for his reputation for 
nearly two centuries. Then came Carlyle, the great historian, 
and public opinion in England now does full justice to Crom- 
well and his motives. 

Reconciliation in America. 
Within a single generation we in America have been able 
as among ourselves, 

"To reap the harvest of perpetual peace, 
By this our bloody trial of sharp war." 

y\fter our war, passion and prejudice also, but only for a 
time, ran riot. 

In 1867 the seceding States were subjected to the horrors 
of Congressional Reconstruction, but in a few years Ameri- 
can manhood had triumphed ; Anglo-Saxon civilization had 
been saved ; local self-government under the Constitution had 
been restored ; ex-Confederates were serving the National 
Government, and true patriots. North and South, were ad- 
dressing themselves to the noble task of restoring fraternal 
feeling between the sections. 

Within a generation after Congressional Reconstruction, 
American historians condemned it, as unqualifiedly as Car- 
lyle, after a lapse of 175 years, did the treatment of Crom- 
well's memory. James Ford Rhodes has denominated Con- 
gressional Reconstruction as "a crime against civilization," and 
public opinion seems to have approved the verdict. 

* * :1; -'fi * * * >|: * ri- 

Many causes had conduced to the fraternal relations that 
existed between the North and South when the war came on 
with Spain in 1898 — the exchange of visits between Union and 
Confederate organizations, the erection in 1895 of a Con- 
federate monument in Chicago, the writings and speeches of 
broad-minded historians, editors, orators and statesmen, but 



more fundamental than all else had been two factors: One, 
the memory of the once much misunderstood Abraham Lin- 
coln and his policies ; the other, the Federal Constitution. 

Abraham Lincoln. 

All men, South as well as North, after the grave had closed 
over Abraham Lincoln, came to see him as he was. He had 
warred for the Union "with charity for all and malice toward 
none." To him the Confederates had always been his "erring 
fellow-citii^ens." He had been the avowed foe of the policy of 
Reconstruction, that was adopted by Congress when he was in 
his grave and could not longer combat it, and, always, he was 
for a Union of co-equal States. 

The South once looked upon Abraham Lincoln as the im- 
personation of all that was odious. Two years ago, although 
there was difference of opinion as to the shape it should take, 
there w^as not a single voice, Northern or Southern, in Con- 
gress against granting him the most costly memorial ever 
voted by that body. 

The Federal Constitution. 

The other factor, the Federal Constitution, was more 
])otent than even the memory of Abraham Lincoln. Its bed- 
rock is the equality of the States — home rule. It was love of, 
and reverence for, home-rule under that Constitution, that 
caused intelligent patriots everywhere to exult when 
the people of the seceding States recovered finally, in the 
seventies, their right of self-government. 

They were not Southerners chafing under the domination of 
the alien and the freedman, but Southerners rejoicing in the 
restoration of home-rule, who were seen flocking to defend the 
flag of the Union in the war with Spain. 

Prior to that war, not only had the Southern States re- 
acquired the right to govern themselves under the Constitu- 
tion, but during the two terms of Grover Cleveland as Presi- 
dent the Southern people had come to feel that they once 
more had their fair share in the administration of the Federal 
Government, and the effect upon them was magnetic. They 
were once more in the home of their fathers. 



The enthusiasm of the vSouth for the flag in the war with 
Spain electrified the North, and when that war was over. 
President McKinley, who had himself been a gallant Union 
soldier, made a speech at Atlanta, December 21, 1898, that 
touched the heart of the South as it never had been touched 
before. In it he said : 

"Sectional lines no longer mar the map of the United 
States, sectional feeling no longer holds back the love we 
bear each other. Fraternity is the National anthem, sung by 
a chorus of 45 vStates and our Territories at home and be- 
yond the seas. The Union is once more the common altar 
of our love and loyalty, our devotion and sacrifice. The 
old flag once again waves over us in peace with new 
glories which your sons and ours have this year added tO' 
its sacred folds." 

Genesis of the Monument. 

Further on he said : 

"And the time has now come, in the evolution of pub- 
lic sentiment and feeling under the Providence of 
God, when in the spirit of fraternity we should share with 
you in the care of the graves of Confederate soldiers." 

This thought was like a seed sown in rich, warm soil; it 
took root at once; then came the plant and its growth, and 
now we have, in this monument, the full flower, already fruit- 
ing into a generous harvest of fraternal feeling. 

On the same trip South at Macon, Ga., an enthusiastic 
Southerner insisted on pinning a Confedrate badge on the lapel 
of Mr. McKinley's coat. The President smilingly wore it. 

Following President McKinley's Speech. 

In their Annual Reunion at Charleston in 1899 the United 
Confederate Veterans thanked the President for his utterances 
at Atlanta. 

In Washington, D. C, a committee of the "Broadway Rouss 
Camp" of Confederate Veterans, of which Dr. Samuel E. 
Lewis was chairman, and two members of which belonged 
also to "Camp 171," began very early to investigate the graves, 
of Confederates in Washington City and its environs. 



General Marcus J. Wright, an ex-Confederate, prepared a 
bill which, on motion of Senator Hawley, of Connecticut, an 
ex-Union soldier, became a law June 6, 1900, under which the 
bodies of 267 Confederate soldiers were gathered into a beau- 
tiful section of the National Cemetery at Arlington, adorned 
with walks and trees, and the name of every soldier, where 
available, was inscribed on a marble headstone. 

The blue-print of the plot of this section, as it came from 
the hands of the officers of the War Department, had the round 
plot in the center marked conspicuously "M." 

The "Broadway Rouss" Committee had co-operated faith- 
fully with the Department officials throughout all this work. 
********** 

On the "Memorial Day," next after the completion of the 
Confederate Section, the ex-Confederate organizations of 
Washington City, after decorating their own graves, "marched 
slowly over to the granite monument representing 2111 Union 
dead, and placed a tribute to Northern valor in the form of a 
large floral shield containing the words from President Mc- 
Kinley's address, 

"In the Name of Fraternity," June 7, 1903. 

And President Roosevelt on that day sent as his tribute to 
the ex-Confederate dead a bountiful supply of beautiful flow- 
ers from the White House. 

But all this had not come about without some opposition. 
The scars left by four years of war were deep, particularly at 
Richmond and New Orleans, and the efforts made by poli- 
ticians, just after the war, to inflame the minds of Northern 
soldiers against their late adversaries, had not been without 
effect. In March, 1901, two prominent Southern women, one 
from Richmond and one from New Orleans, each representing 
what she insisted was the sentiment of the United Daughters 
of the Confederacy, had protested to the Secretary of War that 
the South did not wish its heroes interred at Arlington, but 
intended to remove their remains to its own soil ; and to sup- 
port their protest these ladies cited resolutions by a Post of 
the G. A. R. in Philadelphia, insisting that no monuments or 



inscriptions be permitted in the National Cemetery "that were 
not in honor of the National flag." 

Secretary Root halted the re-interment. 

But soon there came from the Confederate Veterans in 
Annual Reunion at Memphis an unqualified and unanimous 
endorsement of the Act of Congress, and from the U. D. C. 
throughout the country abundant evidence that they, too, de- 
sired the Department to carry on the good work. 

That "the thoughts of men are widened, with the process 
of the suns" is beautifully illustrated by what followed. 

When the week in which the corner-stone of the Confed- 
erate Monument was laid at Arlington in November, 1912, 
with its many patriotic ceremonials, was over, the two pro- 
testing ladies of 1901 expressed themselves as delighted ; and 
in the wonderful Gettysburg Reunion in June, 1913, all the 
Philadelphia G. A. R. Posts joined enthusiastically with their 
comrades throughout the great State of Pennsylvania, in wel- 
coming and heaping honors on ex-Confederates as their guests. 
There was no objection to inscriptions or to Confederate flags 
or uniforms. 

After the Confederate section had been completed, with 
a mound in the center for a monument, the monument be- 
came a certainty. 

A noble rivalry sprang up among Southerners and Southern 
organizations in the District of Columbia as to who should be 
first in the good work of erecting a monument to the Confeder- 
ate dead at Arlington. Every State and large city in the 
South already had its memorials to the Confederate Soldier ; 
it was the duty of Southerners in Washington City to look 
after their dead, now gathered into that Confederate Section 
at Arlington. 

Mrs. Magnus Thompson, President of the Stonewall Jackson 
Chapter U. D. C, urged the matter of a monument at Arling- 
ton on the United Daughters of the Confederacy in their An- 
nual Convention of 1902, and again in 1903 and 1905, but the 
U. D. C. then had their hands full of other matters. The time 
had not yet come for them to take up this work. 

In 1904, the Robert E. Lee Chapter of Washington City, 
Mrs. John M. Hickey, President, began to collect money for 

8 



it. By the 24th of February it had in hand $111.34, and later 
raised this sum to $1,000. The Stonewall Jackson Chapter 
soon afterwards raised $1,000. 

On the 4th of March, 1906, Mrs. Magnus Thompson, Dis- 
trict President U. D. C, through the Hon. John Sharp 
WilHams, obtained from the Hon. William H. Taft, who as 
Secretary of War was ofiicially in charge of National Ceme- 
teries, permission to erect the monument. Secretary Taft, to 
guard against any memorial that might give cause of com- 
plaint to any section of the country, or any inscription that 
might not be acceptable, reserved to the War Department the 
right to supervise both monument and inscription. 

On the 13th of March, 1906, Mrs. Lizzie George Hender- 
son, President-General U. D. C, replying to the Secretary 
and fully recognizing the patriotic purpose that had inspired 
Mr. Taft, thanked him in the name of the U. D. C, adding: 
"And I wish to assure you that the U. D. C, an association 
of fifty thousand women, living in twenty-seven States of 
this Union, will do what they can to foster the kindly feelings 
for all our countrymen now growing up in the hearts of 
us all." 

The time had come to form an organization, and Camp 
171, U. C. v., on the 7th of June, 1906, under a resolution 
moved by Comrade John M. Hickey, appointed a committee 
to "provide ways and means to erect a monument in the Con- 
federate Section at Arlington." The committee was composed 
of Comrades Hickey, Herbert, Shepard, McKim, Callaghan, 
Hare and Carrington. Then on behalf of that committee, 
Comrade H. A. Herbert by letter requested Mrs. Magnus 
jThompson, as Division President of the U. D. C, to call upon 
the various Southern organizations in the District of Columbia 
to send delegations to a joint meeting for the purpose of for- 
warding a monument association. The call was made, the re- 
sult was the "Arlington Confederate Monument Association," 
the personnel of which is given, pp. v, vi, vii, and the work of 
building a Confederate monument at Arlington was now under 
wav. 





^ ^"^fc^ii*?^.^^^**^" -'y >-^;i?i^^ 



EAST FRONT. 



CHAPTER II. 

The Arlington Confederate Monument Association. 

At the Gulfport Convention, of the United Daughters of the 
Confederacy, in November, 1906, the ArHngton Confederate 
Monument Association, which had been founded, as stated in 
Chapter I, at Washington City, appeared by the Chairman of 
its Executive Committee, who presented a petition asking th» 
Convention to assist in the construction of the monum.eni. 
The petition was signed by Mrs. Magnus Thompson, President 
District of Columbia Division, U. D. C, the Presidents of five 
local Chapters, U. D. C, the representatives of Camp 305, 
United Sons of Confederate Veterans and Camp '171, U. C. V. 
The scheme was approved by the Convention and $500.00 
subscribed. 

On the 19th of June, 1907, Mrs. Lizzie George Henderson, 
as President-General of the U. D. C, appeared before the 
Washington A. C. M. Association, and suggested to it in 
writing a plan : "The Arlington Confederate Monument 
Association to go before the U. D. C. Convention in Norfolk 
and ask the U. D. C. to take the work of erecting the monu- 
ment," the U. D. C, and the Veterans and Sons of Veterans 
in the District reserving to themselves certain powers and 
privileges. 

The A. C. M. A. at Washington, had in November, 1907, 
accumulated, counting two sums of $1,000.00 each raised by 
the R. E. Lee and Stonewall Jackson Chapters, $3,460.00, but, 
as they worked, the magnitude and real import of the great 
task they had undertaken grew upon them. The monument 
was to be in the National Cemetery, near the National Capital 
at the former home of Robert E. Lee, and in memory of all 
the Confederate dead. There was wisdom in ]\Irs. Henderson's 
suggestion. When, therefore, the U. D. C. Convention next as- 
sembled the A. C. M. A. was again before it. at Norfolk, by 
the Chairman of its 'Executive Committee, Colonel Hilary A. 



Herbert, this time asking that body to take over the work ivith- 
ont restriction. The trust was accepted unanimously. A com- 
mittee was appointed to draft' a plan for the reorganization of 
the Arlington Confederate Monument Association. This com- 
mittee consisted of Mrs. Augustine T. Smythe, Mrs. Norman 
V. Randolph and Mrs. Ralph Walsh. The plan provided that : 

The President-General U. D. C, was to be ex-oificio Presi- 
dent. One Director was to be appointed in each State, in 
which, the U. D. C. had an organization by the President- 
General, on the recommendation of the State Division Presi- 
dent. 

An Executive Committee at Washington City, to be formed 
of three members from each of the two Camps U. C. V., 
one Camp Sons of Veterans, and three from, each of the five 
Chapters U. D. C. then in the District of Columbia. 

The Executive Committee was empowered to appoint an 
Advisory Board of nine members, the President-General con- 
curring. 

Mrs. Cornelia Branch Stone was elected President-General 
at the Norfolk Convention. Directors were all promptly 
appointed, as provided for in the above scheme, and Mrs. 
Stone went from Norfolk immediately to Washington City 
where, during a stay of two weeks, she put into operation the 
remainder of the plans for the reorganization of the A. C. 
M. A. as provided for by the Convention. Members of an 
Advisory Board were appointed and regulations and by-laws 
formulated by the Executive Committee as then constituted, 
all with the approval of the President-General. 

The personnel of the Association is given on pp. v, vi, vii, as 
of the date of, and prior to the reorganization, and changes 
since made are noted. 

Mrs. Stone was President-General for two years. During 
this period the monument fund had increased rapidly, and, 
at the Houston Convention U. D. C. in 1909, to the retiring 
President the time seemed to have arrived for the appoint- 
ment of a Committee on Design. Mrs. Stone therefore in 
her final report presented six names for ratification as mem- 
bers of a Committee on Design, with a recommendation that 
the Convention should nominate and elect a seventh member, 

12 



who should act as Chairman ; that this Committee should have 
plenary power to select and commission a sculptor and turn 
over the agreement with him to the Executive Committee, 
which was to carry out such agreement in all its details, as 
prescribed by the Committee on Design. 

The Convention adopted this report and elected Mrs. Stone 
as seventh member and Chairman of the Committee on 
Design. 

On the fifth day of November, 1910, in strict accordance 
with the powers that had been granted, a contract was made 
wath Sir Moses Ezekiel to complete at his studio in Rome, 
Italy, within three years, a monument according to a design 
which he had orally outlined to the Committee : price and 
dates of payment being specified in the contract. 

The contract when reported by Mrs. Stone to the U. D. C. 
Convention at Little Rock, Ark., in November, 1910, was 
enthusiastically ratified, and a resolution was passed direct- 
ing that the cost price of the monument as expressed in the 
contract should be increased by $15,000.00, with "hopes of 
increasing" it by the further sum of $25,000. 

The contract for the monument was scon afterwards modi- 
fied by the Executive Committee and the artist as provided 
in this resolution of the Convention. 

The genius of the artist was, under the original contract, 
fettered by nothing except cost price. The enlargement gave 
him wider scope and for three years he devoted himself to 
his great task, working through the summers in the hot climate 
of Rome. The studio in which he had fashioned the creations 
that had made him world-famous was commodious, but for 
this, his "chef-d'oeuvre," he was compelled to erect a special 
building. 

The Sculptor. 

For a brief sketch of the Sculptor we take the following 
extracts from a beautiful paper by Mrs. Charles Herbert 
Silliman entitled "Moses Ezekiel, Sculptor." 

"In Richmond, Va., on the 28th of October, 1S44, Ezekiel 
was born. 

At seventeen he went to Virginia Military Institute, Lex- 

13 



ington. From there in 1864 lie marched with the 225 cadets 
the 100 miles to 'Newmarket,' where — side by side with 
seasoned veterans — these boys planted their company's vic- 
torious flag upon the caisson of splendid Federal forces. All 
the experiences of active service, victory, defeat, feasting upon 
the full garner of the enemy and fasting on their own empty 
one, made impressions upon the youthful patriot that future 
years were to bring forth in deathless marble. 

* * * Above the Speaker's desk in Washington is his head 
of Jefferson ; in the Navy Yard there is his Farragut ; in the 
niches on the outside of the Corcoran Art Gallery are his 
colossal statues of great artists. 

* * * In front of the rotunda of the University of Vir- 
ginia is his Jefferson — spirited, refined, exalted in expression 
— Jefferson in his young manhood, for he was only thirty- 
three when he wrote the Declaration of Independence. 

His Mrs. Fisk and his exquisite recumbent statue of Mrs. 
Andrew D. White, are at Cornell University. So, in many 
places in America, in homes, parks, galleries and institutions, 
his work is found and honored. 

Abroad it is even more widely known and is found in every 
country in Europe. 

The Emperor of Germany and the Grand Duke of Saxe 
Meiningen have conferred upon him the Cavalier Crosses ; 
and the King of Italy the Cross of an Officer of the Crown. 
He has been honored and feted in all possible ways in appreci- 
ation and admiration of his surpassing genius and as a mark 
of the great esteem and love in which he is universally held. 

"In Paris his 'Christ Entombed' reposes in the chapel built 
as a memorial to the victims of that frightful bazaar fire 
w^hich staggered humanity some years ago. One stands in 
awe and silence before this figure of majestic serenity — the 
power of final triumph is upon the beautiful face, and your 
heart is filled with the love that is past understanding. Sir 
Moses always puts the finishing touches himself upon the 
marble, and he devoted three years of patient labor to this 
one. 



14 



His Napoleon has been called the 'History of Napoleon,' 
so comprehensive is it, and it is now in Los Angeles, Cal." 

The artist had never sought the committee, but when called 
before it he had a design already in mind. This he outlined 
as a heroic-sized figure, typifying the South ; in her extended 
left hand a laurel wreath with which to crown the dead; her 
right hand resting on a plow-stock, and underneath, on a cir- 
cular base, figures representing the heroism and sacrifices of 
the men and women of the South. The contract gave the 
artist a free hand. 

While the artist was busy on his task at Rome the work of 
securing funds was being carried on by the splendid body of 
Directors, each in her own State. Every Chapter of the 
U. D. C, was appealed to, and although there were many 
other calls upon them, memorial, educational and charitable, 
it is believed that none failed to respond. Activities in differ- 
ent localities were various and continuous. A generous rival- 
ry between Directors had sprung up and the work was always 
superintended and encouraged by the Presidents-General. The 
Executive Committee at Washington, all the Chapters of the 
U. D. C, in the District of Columbia, and Camp 171 U. C. V., 
were also helping to raise moneys for the monument. 

Some liberal, but no very large, sums were subscribed. 
Small contributions were everywhere encouraged. Many 
thousands put in their mites. Here and there came voluntary 
donations from Union soldiers, but the Arlington Mounment 
is the work of Southern people. 

Mrs. Lizzie George Henderson was President-General 
U. D. C, when the Convention at Gulfport made its first 
•contribution to the monument. Following her as Presidents- 
General came successively Mrs. Cornelia Branch Stone, Mrs. 
Virginia Faulkner McSherry, Mrs. Alexander White, and 
Mrs. Daisy McLaurin Stevens, who officiated at the unveiling. 
All these Presidents-General exercising a general superinten- 
dence over the work kept themselves in constant touch with 
the Executive Committee, cooperating with the Directors, and 
there were always funds on hand to meet every requirement. 



15 





U^- 




WEST FRONT. 



CHAPTER III. 

The U. D. C. at Washington : Layinc; the 
Corner-Stone. 

The gathering-, in 1912, of the U. D. C. in their annual 
Convention at the National Capital to lay the corner-stone of 
their monument, and their wonderful welcome, was a Reunion 
as notable and as fruitful in happy results as was the Gettys- 
burg Reunion during the same year. 

It was the first time the Daughters of the Confederacy had 
convened outside of Dixie. Washington City officially and 
socially flung its doors wide open. That Nation-wide organiza- 
tion, the Daughters of the American Revolution, also opened 
its doors. Through their patriotic President, Mrs. Matthew 
;T. Scott, their home, the beautiful Continental Hall, was 
tendered, and there the Hon. Cuno H. Rudolph, President of 
the District Board of Commissioners, welcomed the U. D. C. 
to W^ashington City, and the President of the United States 
welcomed them to the Nation's Capital. Mr. Taft's speech 
went home to the hearts of the Daughters ; it was history- 
making; the press throughout the Union published it, and 
the Senate of the United States had it printed as a public 
document. 

The speeches of the evening were all received with enthu- 
siam by the audience that filled the building to overflowing. 
The hall was decorated with alternating Confederate and 
Federal flags, and an immense Union banner, all tastefully 
draped and grouped by United States sailors ; flowers came 
from Confederate organizations, private individuals, and the 
White House, and the Marine Band played "Dixie," "The 
Star-Spangled Banner," "My Old Kentucky Home." "Amer- 
ica," and other appropriate selections. 

The corner-stone of the monument at Arlington had been 
laid in the afternoon, and the Reception of the U. D. C. was at 

17 



Continental Hall. 

Evening, November 12, 1912. 

Mrs. Marion Butler, President of the District of Columbia 
Division of the United Daughters of the Confederacy, intro- 
duced the President of the Board of Commissioners of the 
District of Columbia, who heartily welcomed the Daughters 
to the city in glowing words. 

Mrs. Butler next introduced the President of the United 
States, Mr. Taft, saying: 

"This is the first time the Daughters of the Confederacy 
have held an Annual Convention out of the South. We have 
assembled here to lay the corner-stone of a Confederate monu- 
ment, to be erected at Arlington, the Federal Cemetery, the 
former home of Lee. Permission to build this monument was 
granted to the Daughters of the District of Columbia and the 
Confederate Veterans by Mr. Taft when Secretary of War. 
We deem it most fortunate and propitious that we are assem- 
bled in the National Capital for such a purpose and are to be 
welcomed by the same distinguished citizen, who is now Presi- 
dent of the United States. We trust that the building of this 
monument will be the keystone of the arch of a reunited 
country. 

Ladies, the President." 

The President replied as follows : 
"Ladies of the United Daughters of the Confederacy : 

I beg to welcome you to Washington. You have captured 
this city beautiful and made it more lovely by your presence. 
As its temporary head, I give you the freedom of the city, 
and recognize that in what you have done, you have founded a 
shrine and an altar here which will be visited in the future 
by many a faithful pilgrim. 

If the occasion Avhich brings you here were the mourning 
at the bier of a lost cause, I know that the nice sense of 
propriety of a fine old social school would have prevented 
you from inviting me, as the President of the United States, 
to be present. You are not here to mourn or support a cause. 



18 



You are here to celebrate, and justly to celebrate, the heroism, 
the courage and the sacrifice to the uttermost of your fathers 
and your brothers and your mothers and your sisters, and 
of all your kin, in a cause which they believed in their hearts 
to be right, and for which they were willing to lay down their 
lives. That cause ceased to be, except in history, now more 
than half a century ago. It was one which could elicit from 
half a nation, and brave and warlike race, a four year struggle 
in which lives, property, and everything save honor were 
willingly parted with for its sake. So great was the genius 
for military leadership of many of your generals, so adapt- 
able was the individual of your race to effective warlike 
training, so full of patriotic sacrifice were your people that 
now when all the bitterness of the struggle on our part of 
the North has passed away, we are able to share with you 
of the South your just pride in your men and women who 
carried on the unexampled contest to an exhaustion that few 
countries ever suffered. The calm observer and historian, 
whatever his origin, may now rejoice in his heart that the 
Lord ordained it as it is. But no son of the South and no 
son of the North, with any spark in him of pride of race, 
can fail to rejoice in that common heritage of courage and 
glorious sacrifice that we have in the story of the Civil War 
and on both sides in the Civil War. 

It has naturally taken a long time for the spirit of hostility 
that such an internecine struggle develops completely to die 
away. Of course it has lasted a less time with those who 
were the victors and into whose homes and domestic lives 
the borrows of war were not directly thrust. The physical 
evidences of war were traceable in the South for decades 
after they had utterly disappeared in the North in the few 
places in which they existed. Then there are conditions in 
the South which are a constant reminder of the history of the 
past. Until within recent decades, prosperity has not shed 
her boon of comfort upon the South with as generous a hand 
as upon the North. Hence those of us at the North who have 
been sometimes impatient at a little flash now and then of the 
old sectional antagonism are unreasonable in our failure to 
appreciate these marked dift'erences. 

19 



For years after the war, the RepubHcan Party, which had 
carried the nation through the war to its successful conclusion, 
was in control of the administration of the Government, and 
it was impossible for the Southerner to escape the feeling that 
he was linked in his allegiance to an alien nation and one 
with whose destiny he found it difficult to identify himself. 
Time, however, cures much, and after awhile there came a 
Democratic Administration of four years, and then another 
one of four years. Southerners were called to Federal offices, 
they came to have more and more influence in the halls of 
Congress and in the Senate, and the responsibility of the 
Government brought with it a sense of closer relationship 
to it and to all the people for whom the Government was 
carried on. 

I speak for my immediate Republican predecessors in office 
when I say that they all labored to bring the sections more 
closely together. I am sure I can say that, so far as in me has 
lain, I have left nothing undone to reduce the sectional feelings 
and to make the divisions of this country geographical only. 
But I am free to admit that circumstances have rendered it 
more difficult for a Republican Administration than for a 
Democratic Administration, to give to our Southern brothers 
and sisters the feeling of close relationship and ownership in 
the Government of the United States. Therefore, in solving" 
the mystery of that Providential dispensation which now brings 
on a Democratic Administration to succeed this, we must admit 
the good that will come to the whole country in a more con- 
firmed sense of partnership in this Government which our 
brothers and sisters of the Southland will enjoy in an Adminis- 
tration, in which Southern opinion will naturally have greater 
influence, and the South greater proportionate representation 
in the Cabinet, in Congress, and in other high official stations. 
While I rejoice in the steps that I have been able to take to 
heal the wounds of sectionalism and to convey to the Southern 
people, as far as I could, my earnest desire to make this 
country one, I can not deny that my worthy and distinguished 
successor has a greater opportunity, and I doubt not he will 
use it for the benefit of the nation at large. 

It fell to my official lot, with universal popular approval, to 

20 



issue the order which made it possible to erect, in the National 
Cemetery of Arlington, the beautiful monument to the heroic 
dead of the South that you founded today. The event in itself 
speaks volumes as to the oblivion of sectionalism. It gives me 
not only great pleasure and great honor, but it gives me the 
greatest satisfaction as a lover of my country, to be present, 
as President of the United States, and pronounce upon this 
occasion the benediction of all true Americans." 

The President was given an ovation, the convention rising 
in appreciation of his greeting. 

Mrs. Frank G. Odenheimer of the Maryland Division, First 
Vice-President, U. D. C, expressing regret at the absence of 
the President-General, Mrs. White, introduced Mrs. Monroe 
McClurg, of Mississippi, who responded to the welcome as 
follows: 

Across the radiance of this brilliant occasion one shadow 
rests, caused by the absence of our President-General, Mrs. 
Alexander B. White, who is kept away from her beloved 
Daughters by the demands of a closer love, a love that binds 
with hooks of steel. She has given me the happy privilege 
of expressing the appreciation of the United Daughters of 
the Confederacy for the golden words of welcome which have 
greeted us to night. 

In the name of the President-General and her loyal Daugh- 
ters, permit me, Mr. President, to assure, you that we appreci- 
ate highly the honor of having you with us tonight. We will 
keep you in our hearts, not only for your gracious words of 
welcome, but because it was your act as Secretary of War 
that made possible the beautiful ceremonies out at Arlington 
this afternoon. 

We knew that our Veterans and our sister Daughters w^ould 
greet us with outstretched hands and joyous words of welcome, 
because we come from the land of Dixie. 

Mr. Commissioner, you have told well the story of the glory 
of your city. 

In the past the South has often sent to you of her best — • 
to occupy the White House, to sit on the Supreme Bench and 
to fill many other positions of honor and trust. But tonight 

21 



she has sent and placed within your tender care her crown 
jewels, her women, the flower of Southern womanhood, the 
United Daughters of the Confederacy. 

All around us "Old Glory" waves. Our flag, that flag which 
was baptized in Southern blood, and the stars which the South 
added in the field of blue, shed splendor on the Nation's glory. 
On every side we hear familiar names, household words — 
Washington, Arlington, Mount V^ernon, Alexandria, George- 
town, which make us feel very much at home. 

And as this royal welcome is given because we are the 
United Daughters of the Confederacy, it will not be amiss to 
speak briefly of our work, and it must necessarily be a general 
statement. 

We know that it is difficult for those not allied to us by 
ties of blood to understand how we Southern women, Ameri- 
can women, teaching our children the loftiest patriotism — to 
glory in, to honor and support the Stars and Stripes — yet fold 
close to their hearts and swear eternal allegiance to a blood- 
stained banner forever furled, "for of all the instincts of the 
human heart there is none more difficult of analysis than love 
of country, altogether inscrutable, altogether beyond the power 
of description, is that silent voice. Vague it may be, vague 
as the pale gray smoke of fire, drifting on an Indian summer's 
evening along the hillsides, mysterious as the glint of the 
moon rays through barren, wind-swayed branches, subtle as 
the sound of moving waters, but he must be blind or deaf 
indeed who would deny it the mighty strength of a passion 
woven from the fibres of the first heart that ever throbbed 
in the misty dawn of time." This passionate love the United 
Daughters of the Confederacy have for the South — a love 
beyond analysis. 

We stand a patriotic society unique in the history of the 
world. And our objects 

First, That the truths of history, shall be taught to the youth 
of our land. And, while we would not needlessly stir the 
embers of a settled strife or reopen the gaves of buried issues 
or by one word revive the bitter memories of the stormy past, 
it is due the truth of history that the fudamental principles 
for wjjiicji our fathers contended should be often reiterated, in 

99 



order that the purpose which inspired them may be correctly- 
estimated and the purity of their motives vindicated. If one 
has a clear and accurate knowledge of the nature and character 
of the Federal Government, together with the rights of the 
States under the Constitution, we need not fear the judgments 
that may be formed and the conclusions that will be reached. 
So the United Daughters of the Confederacy stand for the 
truths of history. 

Second. Memorial. Poor is the country that boasts no 
heroes, but beggared is that people who, having them, forget. 
The South has her heroes, her immortals who add glory to 
American history, and ''we of the .South remember; we of the 
South revere." 

The Daughters are making it a historic land, filling it with 
mounments of granite and marble, tablets of bronze and brass 
that say to the world of the Confederate soldier, the Con- 
federate sailor and the Confederate statesman. "They shall 
be remembered forever ; they shall live forever ; they shall be 
speaking forever: the people shall know them forever." 

Just across the river lies beautiful Arlington. Arlington ! 
The very name will be a memorial forever to the South's 
knightliest son. Gen. Robert E. Lee. 

Third. Benevolence. With our Veterans it is "sunset and 
evening star." We, their Daughters, keep ever in our hearts 
the sacred duty we owe. We see that comfortable homes are 
provided for those in need and tender care given to the 
helpless. 

Fourth. Educational. Chapters, Divisions and the General 
Organization are establishing and maintaining scholarships for 
the descendants of Confederate Veterans, for the Daughters 
believe that an education is the best asset that a boy or girl 
can have, and that an intelligent citizenship is the best asset 
that a nation can have. 

Fifth. Social. To keep alive the ties of friendship between 
the women of the South, that, no matter how far they roam, 
they will have a common interest — their proudest heritage — 
"Our fathers wore the Southern cross of honor." And this 
great organization of women, who appreciate so deeply the 
welcome given them tonight, hold fast to the priceless heritage 

23 



— love, honor, cherish it — say reverently, in spirit and truth : 
"We humbly thank Thee, Almighty Father, for the past 
history of our covmtry and for the inspiring reflection that, 
notwithstanding the disappointments and sorrows of our Con- 
federate history, we came through its great trial and struggle 
with our battered shields pure, our characters as a brave and 
courageous people untarnished and nothing to regret in our 
faithful defense of the honor and rights of our Southland." 

These two speeches were eloquent and they were dramatic. 
Mr. Taft stood for the North and the Nation; Mrs. McClurg 
stood for the South. 

And the setting was dramatic. The Daughters of the Ameri- 
can Revolution, an Association born of the War for American 
Independence, had invited into their home the Daughters of 
the Confederacy, a body born of the War between the States. 

These two bodies of noble women are akin ; each traces its 
lineage back to a heroic struggle for human rights ; each is 
animated by ancestral pride and the loftiest patriotism, and 
both stand for the truths of history. But they differ in this : 
there has been nothing to arouse in the D. A. R., as an organi- 
zation, the mother instinct — no call on their sympathies. The 
struggle, out of which, they were born, established independent 
States to provide for the wants of free and happy peoples. 
But the Confederacy had established no government to care 
for those who were left destitute and bereft ; the mother in- 
stinct in the hearts of the Daughters of the Confederacy was 
enkindled, and they stand not only for the high and noble 
purposes that animate the Daughters of the American Revo- 
lution, but also for the education of the orphan, for the care 
of the veteran in the sunset of life. 

It was the mother instinct, the love of the living and the 
desire to care for them, as much as the wish to perpetuate the 
memory of the dead, that brought together the Daughters of 
the Confederacy. At the cry of the destitute, no matter what 
the cost. 

"A mother is a mother still. 
The holiest thing alive." 

24 



Mr. Tait happily spoke of the Daughters of the Con- 
federacy as beloug-ing to "a fine old social school," and Mrs. 
McClurg aptly denominated them as "the flower of Southern 
womanhood." They are the descendants and typical repre- 
sentatives of the men who controlled the Government at 
Washington for many years before the war, of the soldiers 
who fouglit the battles of the Confederacy and of those who, 
by tlieir courage and devotion during the two decades after 
the war, were the saviors of Anglo-Saxon civilization in their 
section. 

Of the four who have been Presidents-General of the organi- 
zation since it took up the monument, the first, Mrs. Cornelia 
Branch Stone, a daughter of Edward T. Branch a distinguished 
Congressman and Supreme Court Judge of the Republic of 
Texas. 

Tlie next in order was Mrs. Virginia Faulkner McSherry, 
whose father, Charles James Faulkner, was a noted Virginian 
vStatesman and diplomat before the war. Then came Mrs. 
Alexander B. White. 

Mrs. Alexander White's father was E. Hopkins, Captain 
in the celebrated 38th Mississippi Volunteers and every 
male of the family was in the Confederate service. The present 
incumbent is the daughter of Senator McLaurin, of Mississippi. 

Anselm Joseph McLaurin enlisted in 1864 as a Confederate 
Soldier at sixteen and served till the close of the war between 
the States, was Governor of Mississippi and twice elected as 
United States Senator, dying in office. 

Of the old Southern strain are not only the heads of the 
Chapters and other officials of the U. D. C, but every member 
is and must be of blood kin to some soldier of the Con- 
federacy. It was this representative body of women that was 
now at the National Capital to lay the corner-stone of the 
monument, which, as General Bennett Young said when it was 
imveiled, "promises a blessed future in which sectional hate 
shall be fully translated into fraternity and good will." 

On the morning after their reception at Continental Hall 
the regular proceedings of the Convention began at the New 
Willard Hotel, ending on the 16th of November. No body 
of women ever made a deeper impression on the Washington 

25 



public and the newspaper men than did the U. D. C, and no 
small part of the commendation they received was due to the 
dignity and ability of Mrs. F. S. Odenheimer, First Vice- 
President, who presided in place of JMrs. Alexander B. White, 
detained at home by the critical illness of her husband. 
Throughout the week, during every interval of business, all 
the delegates, and even in business hours such delegates as 
had leisure, were busy in attending hospitalities extended by 
citizens and officials in Washington, and even in Maryland. 
Receptions were given at the Wliite House by the President 
and Mrs. Taft ; at the beautiful Congressional Library, at 
the New Willard by the U. D. C. officials, and finally, on 
invitation of the Representatives of the Central and South 
American States, there was on Friday evening a brilliant 
gathering of Daughters of the Confederacy, Veterans and Sons 
of Veterans, society folk and national officials, at the mag- 
nificent Pan-American Building. 

It was a week that brought home to the heart of every 
U. D. C. delegate the feeling that beautiful Washington City 
is the Capital of all the people and dear to the heart of every 
citizen in the land. 

That the Convention was appreciative fully appears in the 
eloquent report of its Committee on Thanks, read by Mrs. 
Eugenia Dorothy Blount Lamar. It occupies three and a half 
pages of the printed ''Minutes." The report named the great 
speech of the President, and those of Mr. Bryan, Mr. Tanner, 
and of the Master of Ceremonies at the laying of the corner- 
stone. As specimens the following paragraphs are copied : 

"The good fellowship and glory in a common heritage of 
American valor has been strengthened during this week, by 
the gracious hospitality extended by the Daughters of the 
American Revolution to the United Daughters of the Con- 
federacy and we would heartily thank them and their mag- 
nificent leader, Mrs. Matthew T. Scott. 

To Mr. Wallace Streater, Treasurer of the Arlington Monu- 
ment Association, for untiring efforts in behalf of our great 
project and for continuous service to this organization. 

"To Mrs. Marion Butler, for head and heart can find nothing 
lacking in what she, as representative of the District of Co- 

26 



lumbia Division, has done for making this the red-letter occa- 
sion in the life of the United Daughters of the Confederacy. 
Ever\^ woman of this organization would exclaim, "She has 
done great things for us and for our people." 

To the President and Mrs. Taft for the beautiful reception 
tendered us in the White House. 

To Camp 171, U. C. V., Washington, D. C, to the Annapo- 
lis Chapter, U. D. C, to the Governor of Maryland and Mrs. 
Goldsborough, to Alexandria Chapter, U. D. C, to Mrs. 
William C. Story, to Miss Nannie Heth, President of South- 
ern Relief Society, to Mrs. P.osalia Bocock, and the members 
of the Committee on Entertainment, to Mr. John Barrett, 
Director-General of the Pan-American Union, the Southern 
Society of Washington, and the Southern Commercial Con- 
gress, to all Chapter Presidents and members of the District of 
Columbia, to Mrs. Drury C. Ludlow, Chairman of Credential 
Committee and Second Vice-President, we hereby express pro- 
found gratitude for generous courtesies. 

Thanks to Governor Goldsborough, Annapolis Chapter, for 
luncheon at Carvel Club; Alexandria Chapter for lunch while 
visiting historic xMexandria. 

For delightful social functions we thank Miss Alice Bristol, 
Mrs. Marion Butler, Col. Hilary A. Herbert, Mrs. Benjamin 
Micou, Mrs. S. A. Willis, Mrs. Phoebe Seabrook, Mrs. Harriet 
Turner. Mr. and Mrs. Arthur Johnson, Mrs. Samuel Spencer. 

In the language of a psychologist and dramatist of modern 
times, 'Thanks for everything.' " 

Laying the Corner-Stone. 

On a lovely autumn day, amid enthusiastic thousands, with 
Federal and Confederate flags flying overhead and tastefully 
festooned round about, with the speakers' stand and grounds 
decorated with flowers from U. D. C. Chapters, U. C. V, 
and S. C. V. Camps, from private individuals, and the White 
House, and with the shouts of the multitude greeting the 
speakers and mingling with the patriotic music, the follow- 
ing program was carried out : 



27 



Program. 

Program of the Laying of the Corner-Stone of the ArHngton 

Monument, Arhngton, Va., Tuesday, 

November 12, 1912, 2 P.M. 

Mrs. F. G. Odenheimer, First Vice-President U. D. C. 
Presiding Officer. 

Col. Hilary A. Herbert, Master of Ceremonies. 

Musical Program to be Given by the Fifteenth Cavalry Band, 
Arthur Whitcomb, Band Master. 

1. Grand Selection. "Southern Melodies" Lampe 

2. Invocation Bishop Robert A. Gibson, of Virginia 

3. Paraphrase, ''Nearer My God to Thee." 

4. List of articles placed in box for corner-stone, 

Mr. Wallace Streater 

5. Laying Corner-Stone Col. Hilary A. Herbert 

6. Cornet solo, "The Lost Chord" Sullivan 

7. Introduction of Mr. Bryan, 

By Mrs. Alexander B. White, President-General, U. D. C. 
Address Col. William Jennings Bryan 

8. National Air, "My Country 'Tis of Thee." 

9. Benediction Dr. Randolph H. McKim 

"Star-Spangled Banner." 

The invocation by Bishop Gibson was deeply impressive, and 
w^hen the strains of "Nearer My God to Thee," by the band 
had died away, Col. Herbert, Master of Ceremonies, before 
laying the corner-stone, spoke as follows : 

^'Daughters of the Confederacy, Comrades, Fellow 
Americans: 
"The Constitution of the United States was a new experi- 
ment in government. It undertook to divide sovereignty be- 
tween the States and the Federal Government. For twelve 
years the question as to who should decide between the Fed- 
eral Government and a State when a dispute should arise gave 
trouble. It seriously threatened the perpetuity of the Union. 
But it was at last settled to the satisfaction of a majority of 

28 



the people of that day by the election of Thomas Jefferson 
to the Presidency. For twenty-four years Jefferson, Madison 
and Monroe administered the Government upon the State rights 
theory, the theory that had been propounded by Jefferson 
himself, the author of the Declaration of Independence, and 
by Madison, that the Constitution created a union of co-equal 
States, each zvith the right to judge for itself of infractions 
of the Constitution and of the mode and manner of redress. 
Here was the germ of secession. Under this theory the Gov- 
ernment possessed no power to protect itself against disin- 
tegration. Jefferson, Madison and Monroe loved the Union. 
Tfliey all hoped that it would be perpetual ; that it would grow 
in favor, and there would never be reason for secession. It 
was a beautiful theory, and was perhaps, for the time being, 
the salvation of the Union. It restored contentment and 
brought in the 'era of good feeling.' Only one electoral vote 
was cast against Monroe at his last election. 

"The next notable period lasted from 1830 to 1860. It was 
an era of unrest and discord. Slavery, an institution that 
came from the colonies, had drifted into the South. A dis- 
pute involving the morality of slavery and of slaveholders and 
many constitutional questions now arises between the North 
and South. It continues for many years. During all this 
time Union sentiment is growing at the North, the State rights 
theory in the South, and finally a storm of passion and preju- 
dice drives the Southern States into secession and the country 
into the vortex of war. These States set up the Constitution 
of the fathers over themselves and seek to maintain it. The 
North fights to maintain that same Constitution over the whole 
Union. The stern arbiter that has decided vexed questions 
since nations began ; that has settled every boundary between 
the nations in Europe — war — war that made independent 
States of thirteen British colonies, now settles forever the 
question of secession. Incidentally, thank God, slavery dis- 
appears. 

"Then comes in another era. the period from 1865 to the 
great peace jubilee in 1899. The States, when they seceded, 
did not consider that withdrawal from the Union was rebellion 
or revolution. They had based their action on Jeff'erson's idea 

29 



that the Constitution was a compact ; that each party to it had 
the right to judge for itself of an infraction of that compact 
and of the mode and manner of redress. But now they ac- 
cept without question the decision of the arbiter to which they 
had submitted their contention, and slowly they tread the 
thorny path of reconstruction back into the Union. 

"Time is the blessed mother of reconciliation. The embers 
of passion die out. The kindly winds of heaven blow away 
the smoke of battle. Everywhere our people are engaged in 
the arts of peace. The bright sunshine falls upon green fields 
and growing crops. Trade flows where armies trod. Com- 
merce floats where ships of war sailed. Respect, confidence, 
and mutual admiration take the place of hatred and distrust. 
Ex-Confederates in Congress help to maintain the army and 
build up the navy. The questions that once divided the North 
and the South are settled forever. People North and South 
see each other as they are, and the Union is more complete 
than ever before. 

"Note the difference between the old and the new era. 
■Against the declaration of war with Great Britain in 1812 
there were thirty-two votes in the House of Representatives. 
When Palo Alto and Resaca de la Palma had already been 
fought there were in that same body fourteen votes negativing 
even the existence of war with Mexico. But now, when Mr. 
Cleveland sends in his Venezuelan message, in which the 
honor of the country is concerned, every vote in the House 
and Senate maintains it. 

"Now look again. War is declared against Spain and the 
vote in Congress is unanimous. In this era, when questions 
confront us involving the honor of the flag, there are no par- 
ties — Democrats and Republicans all are for our country, 
and in the war with Spain, Butler and Wheeler and Fitz Lee, 
ex-Confederate veterans, are wearing the blue as generals 
alongside of their former foes. Shafter, Brooke and Miles. 

"That was a great jubilee at W^ashington in 1899. It 
marked, not only peace with Spain, but signified everlasting 
peace between the North and South. 

"The present is the era, not only of honors to the dead, but 
of justice to the motives and patriotism of both Union and 

30 



Confederate soldiers. The historian no longer repeats the 
falsehood that the men who lie here before us and their com- 
rades who sleep on a thousand battlefields died that slavery 
might live, or that the soldiers who rest in those graves over 
there enlisted to set the negroes free. That was not the issue 
upon which war between the North and South was fought. 
Four-fifths of the Confederate soldiers were non-slaveholders, 
and the soldiers in blue did not enlist to emancipate the slave. 
They fought for the Union; the Confederates for independ- 
ence. All were freemen, fighting for the perpetuity of free 
institutions. The survivors of the two armies, and civilians 
as well. North and South, now vie with each other in honor- 
ing both the Federal and Confederate dead. Robert E. Lee, 
once called a traitor because he resigned from the old army 
to ofifer his service to his native State, is now recognized as one 
of Nature's noblemen. His name adorns the Hall of Fame in 
the city of New York. His statue is in the Capitol at Wash- 
ington. Charles Francis Adams, in his noble eulogy at Lex- 
ington, Va., Morris Schaff, another brave Union general, in 
his 'Sunset of the Confederacy,' and many others have joined 
in the chorus that is coming up from the North of praise for 
Lee and his soldiers. 

"It is to these soldiers that we are to erect this monument — 
the rank and file of the Confederate armies — the men whose 
courage and devotion lifted Robert E. Lee, Albert Sidney 
Johnston, Joseph E. Johnston and Stonewall Jackson higher 
and higher till they wrote their names among the stars. The 
rank and file of the Grand Army of the Republic are joining 
Northern orators and historians. A typical instance is a mon- 
ument erected in 1907 on the hard-fought battlefield of Salem 
Church, Va., by the Survivors' Association of the brave 
Twenty-third New Jersey Regiment. On one side is an appro- 
priate inscription to their own gallant comrades; on the other 
a tablet with the inscription : 

" 'To the brave Alabama boys who were our opponents on 
this field, and whose memory we honor, this tablet is dedicated.' 

"Magnanimity that is unparalleled in history ! 

"Contributions toward the monument, excepting one gen- 
erous gift of $500, have come in little by little, from many 

31 



thousands. The money has come chiefly from Southern 
sources. The memorial will thus represent Confederate sen- 
timent. But it represents even more than that. The survivors 
of the Twenty-third New Jersey Regiment, unsolicited, sent 
in $100. Other contributions have been voluntarily made by 
Union soldiers. 

"The memorial is being constructed on his own design at 
Rome, Italy, by the great artist. Sir Moses Ezekiel. The chief 
figure is that of a woman, representing the South; her ex- 
tended left hand holds a wreath of laurel with which to crown 
the Confederate dead ; her right rests upon a plow stock, on 
which is a pruning hook. Underneath an inscription reads : 
'They have beat their swords into plowshares and their spears 
into pruning hooks.' 

"Our hope is to unveil the completed monument on one of 
the last days of June next year, just prior to the great reunion 
between the survivors of both armies on the battlefield of 
Gettysburg, that begins on the first of July, 1913. 

"We are in America's second era of good feeling. In the first 
it was only a dream of the fathers that the Union would be 
perpetual, a dream inspired by the belief that because the 
theory of State rights was then generally accepted there never 
would be cause for secession. Now we know that the Union 
is to be perpetual, because there never can be secession, that 
question having been settled forever. To us has come, instead 
of uncertainty, certainty. Ours is the substance of what the 
fathers only hoped for. It has been given to us to see with 
our own eyes what their prophetic vision could not have fore- 
cast — the material prosperity, the grandeur, the power of this 
united Republic as it is today. Our eyes have seen, too, the 
unspeakable horrors of disunion — an outpouring during four 
years of war of blood and treasure which it never could have 
entered into the imagination of our ancestors to conceive, and 
for which nothing could atone except the exaltation of this 
hour, in which there comes to us from every battlefield of our 
great war memories of heroic deeds that have brought us closer 
together in a union to present which our posterity will never 
be called upon to make sacrifices. 

"And now, speaking for myself and my surviving comrades, 

Z2 



we thank the noble body of women who have made sure the 
noble monument that is soon to rise on this spot. We thank 
the Giver of all good that He has bounteously lengthened out 
our lives that we might behold this glorious day, and that He 
gave us the courage to stand in the day of battle by the side of, 
and be able to claim comradeship with, the soldiers in whose 
memory I am about to lay this corner-stone. Before doing it 
let me read a telegram just received from our artist at Rome. 
It is in Latin. I translate it thus : 

"'Rome, November 11, 1912. 
" 'Where the eternal spirit of the Father of his Country still 
watches, announce to the nations that you have seen lying 
here heroes who nobly died that the majesty of the law and our 
republican institutions might stand. Ezekiel.' '■■ 

Here a box was placed beneath the resting place of the 
corner-stone before it was laid, by Mr. Wallace Streater, who 
read aloud the contents of the box as follows : 

1. Certified copy of that portion of the Act of Congress 
approved June 6, 1900, Chapter 791, which authorized the 
reburial of the remains of certain Confederate soldiers in 
Arlington National Cemetery. 

2. History of the Confederate section, Arlington National 
Cemetery, with list of dead therein buried, by Dr. Samuel 
E. Lewis. 

3. Early history of Arlington Confederate Monument As- 
sociation. 

4. Transcript of the minutes of the Norfolk Convention of 
the United Daughters of the Confederacy, 1907, creating the 
Arlington Confederate Monument Association and defining 
its duties and scope of authority. 

5. Roster of Arlington Confederate Monument Association. 

6. Letter from William Howard Taft, Secretary of War, 
giving authority to build monument. 

7. Duplicate of receipt No. 1, given by Wallace Streater, 
Treasurer Arlington Confederate Monument Association, to 
Robert E. Lee Chapter No. 644, United Daughters of the Con- 
federacy, Washington, D. C, for $1,000. 

33 



8. Samples of official stationery of Arlington Confederate 
Monument Association. 

9. Photograph of models of monument so far as completed, 
made in the studio of Sir Moses Ezekiel, sculptor, Rome, Italy. 

10. Minutes of the Richmond Convention, 1911, United 
Daughters of the Confederacy. 

11. Complete roster of Chapters, United Daughters of the 
Confederacy, of the District of Columbia. 

12. Complete roster of the Camps of the United Confederate 
Veterans of the District of Columbia. 

13. Complete roster of Washington Camp No. 305, United 
Sons of Confederate Veterans, of the District of Columbia. 

14. Roster of the Southern Relief Society of the District 
of Columbia. 

15. United States flag. 

16. The flag of the United Daughters of the Confederacy. 

17. Flags of States wherein Chapters of the United Daugh- 
ters of the Confederacy are located, Alabama, Arizona, 
Arkansas, California, Colorado, District of Columbia, Florida, 
Illinois, Kentucky, Louisiana, Maryland, Mexico, Mississippi, 
Missouri, Minnesota, Nebraska, New York, North Carolina, 
Ohio, Oklahoma, Oregon, Pennsylvania, South Carolina, Ten- 
nessee, Texas, Utah and Virginia. 

18. Fac simile of the Declaration of Independence, 1776. 

19. Plaster cast of the great seal of the Confederate States. 

20. Specimens of Confederate money from 50 cents to $100. 

21. Twenty-five-cent shinplaster of South Carolina. 

22. Confederate bill — $10 — with poem by Jonah, printed on 
reverse. 

23. Confederate stamps. 

24. The James Confederate stamp seal. 

25. Small coin of the year when Arlington Confederate 
Monument Association was organized (1907). 

26. Small coin made in 1912. 

27. Names of President and Cabinet in 1906, when permis- 
sion was granted to build monument. 

28. Names of President and Cabinet in 1912, when corner- 
stone of monument was laid. 

29. Copy of Act of March 9, 1906, providing for the mark- 

54 



ing of the graves of the soldiers and sailors of the Confederate 
Amy and Navy who died in Northern prisons and were buried 
near the prisons where they died, and the report of the Senate 
Committee thereon. 

30. Life of the youngest Confederate soldier. 

31. Washington Evening Star, November 11, 1912. 

32. Washington Times, November 11, 1912. 

33. Washington Herald, November 11, 1912. 

34. Washington Post, November 11, 1912. ' 

35. Sheet of paper on which in the handwriting of Col. Wm. 
Jennings Bryan, the speaker at laying of corner-stone, is given 
the text of his remarks. "A man deviseth his way, but the 
Lord directeth his steps." Proverbs. 16-9. 

36. Official tickets and badges in use at the Nineteenth An- 
nual Convention of the United Daughters of the Confederacy, 
Washington, D. C, November 12-16, 1912. 

37. Official program of the Nineteenth Annual Convention, 
United Daughters of the Confederacy. 

38. Official program of exercises coincident to laying corner- 
stone Arlington Confederate Monument, November 12, 1912. 

39. List of articles placed in corner-stone. 

Mrs. F. G. Odenheimer, Vice- President-General \J. D. C. ; 
Miss Mary Custis Lee, daughter of General Lee; Mr. Wallace 
Streater and Col. Herbert, Master of Ceremonies, then laid 
the corner-stone. 

"Corporal James Tanner," ex Commander in Chief of the 
G. A. R., assisted, and while they were engaged in this task 
Col. Herbert asked Mr. Tanner and he consented to speak 
briefly after Mr. Bryan. 

Hon. William Jennings Bryan then delivered an address, 
which unfortunately was not fully reported. 

Pie said 'in part : 

"This is an occasion that brings gladness to my heart." said 
Col. Bryan. "I have welcomed every evidence of a reuniting 
country, and there is nO occasion in which 1 could participate 
with more pleasure than one like this. 

'Tt is appropriate that the erection of this' monument should 
be intrusted to the United Daughters of the Confederacy — that 

35 



splendid organization which has called forth the energies of the 
women of the 'South and brought them into co-operation in 
the doing of so much for the welfare of their sections and the 
country. 

"Woman — last at the cross 'and first at the sepulcher — holds 
undisputed sway on occasions like this. Her ministrations in- 
voke the sweet and sacred memories that link us to a brilliant 
past, while she points us 'to the brighter visions of the future. 

"It is fitting, too, that the Daughters of the Revolution 
should participate in these exercises, for both North and 
Sbuth inherit from the patriots of 'colonial days. 

"And it is entirely proper that the President of the United 
States should welcome to the' National Capital those who come 
upon so laudable a mission as that which inspires the city's 
guests. 

"The North and South 'jointly contributed to the causes 
that produced the war between the States. They share to- 
gether the responsibility for the introduction of slavery ; they 
bore together the awful sacrifices that the conflict compelled 
and they inherit together the glories of the struggle, written in 
bravery and devotion. Enormous as was the cost and bitter 
as were 'the animosities that were aroused, charity and forgive- 
ness have sprung up like flowers from the battlefields and 
their fragrance will endure. 

"The Capital City is the place for such a -monument and we 
must confess that it is not complimentary to us that its build- 
ing has been so long delayed. In 'this throbbing heart of the 
nation's political life the monument whose corner-stone we lay 
today will stand as a visible jjroof of the harmony and concord 
that make 'our nation one. 

Pledge of Peace. 

"On the summit of the Andes, where Argentina and Chile 
meet, the representatives of the two countries have 'placed a 
bronze statue of Christ. It is a heroic figure and represents 
the Prince of Peace, one hand holding aloft the cross, 'the 
other stretched forth as if invoking a benediction. Around 
it are the snowclad peaks of that lofty mountain range. It 

36 



embodies a sublime sentiment, and the monument is in itself a 
pledge of perpetual peace between the nations. 

"So let this monument be emblematic of our nation's unity 
of aim and purpose. Standing on the line that once separated 
two unfriendly sections, it becomes a bond of unity, and, 
breathing the spirit of Ilini who laid 'the foundations of a uni- 
versal brotherhood, it will be to the country a promise of never- 
ending good will." 

Mr. Bryan was loudly applauded. 

"Corporal James Tanner" was here introduced by the 
Master of Cerem,onies, and said : 

"I would have serious reproach to make of my friend, Her- 
bert, for drafting me on this occasion if I did not know that 
his act, which places me before you, to your surprise and 
mine, was born out of the generous impulse of his heart. I 
could have wished in justice to'myself that I could have had a 
little more notice — an hour or so — that I was to have this 
honor, for it is a fact that it was only when we 'stood down 
there laying the corner-stone that he told me he was not going 
to close the exercises until 'he had called on me to say some- 
thing. I felt that I could not decently say *No,' and I had no 
disposition so to do. I accept his detail; I obey 'his order. 

"I expected when I came here to remain a quiet spectator and 
listener, glad to be here, cordially approving with all my heart 
the purpose and the occasion which has brought us together. 
I recall as I stand before you that just after the bill' was in- 
troduced in Congress, setting aside this plot in which to inter 
the remains of the Confederate dead, 'when our latest martyr 
President, the lovable McKinley, was in the White House. I 
had business with him one evening and when we had finished 
the matter in hand and I arose to depart, he detained me and 
asked if I had noticed the bill in question. I answered that 
I had. He asked me what I thought of it. I answered him 
that he and I served and fought and that we did not make 
war upon dead men nor bear animosity toward them ; that I 
hoped and believed that the bill would pass unanimously ; and 
that if I sat where he did, I would certainly sign it. His hand 
came out in a warm grasp as he said : 'I am glad to hear you 
talk like that, Tanner. I shall sign it as soon as it reaches 
my desk.' 

o/ 



"I am happy in the knowledge, standing in this presence 
today and on an occasion bound to be of historic note in all 
the future of our nation, that I have not to attune my tongue 
to any new line of thought to express to you, no new ideas 
to present on the subject of the South erecting memorials to 
her battlefield heroes. Years ago I expressed myself clearly 
and unmistakably on this subject. The time I did so some of 
you can locate easier than I. It was when the news went out 
on the wings of the press that it was proposed to erect in 
Chicago a monument in memory of the six thousand Southern 
dead buried there. 

"This notice brought to me a much inflamed letter from one 
who claimed to be a Union veteran. He was very peremptory 
in his demand to know what I thought of 'this proposed out- 
rage of erecting on Northern soil a monument in memory of 
Rebel dead ;' and he demanded that my 'voice ring out in 
denunciation thereof.' I answered him at once and I said 
to him as I say to you today that wherever on this broad 
earth there exists a people who will encourage their manhood 
of any and all ages to go out and battle for a cause and then 
will permit those who gave their lives in sacrifice to that 
cause to lie in unmarked sepulchre and the memory of them 
to die out, they are a people regarding whom I have no power 
of expression with wdiich to convey to you the measure of 
scorn and contempt I feel therefor; and I gave my corre- 
spondent full permission to ring those sentiments out as loud 
and as far as he cared or could. 

"In my library there is a small but treasured volume, rich 
in its expression of lofty sentiment, which came to me from 
the author thereof, who, I am frank to confess, was one of 
the loves of my life among men. He wore the gray ; I wore 
the blue. But on the fly-leaf of that volume he inscribed the 
sentiment — 'All brave men are true comrades.' The signature 
was that of the lion-hearted, sweet-souled John W. Daniel of 
Virginia. He and I had much in common, symbolized in part 
by his crutch and my cane. 

"As we sat at times in social converse, though each carried 
physical reminders of the searing effects of the contest which 
would remain with us until the grave should close over us, 



38 



and though our brows might be furrowed with pain, there was 
never a moan in our hearts. We had each played our part in 
the mighty game of the 60's and if to us had fallen the rough 
end of it, still it was in the game. We resolutely set our faces 
to the front for the speedy restoration of unity, good feeling, 
and perfect peace between the hitherto discordant sections of 
our country. Daniel kept his face consistently that way until 
God took him. I face that way yet and shall until the end 
comes. And it is that spirit which has so readily brought me 
to my feet here today. 

"We of both sides, as we were aligned of old, want you 
young men — the men of today — to bear in mind that we old 
fellows met these issues in the long ago and we fought them 
out ; we settled them for all time. Today the feet of innocent 
children picking flowers press the sod once torn by the ruthless 
wheels of artillery. Cannons rusting in disuse are enmeshed 
in clinging vines, and the birds in safety build their nests in 
the mouths that once belched death and destruction. We have 
brought to you a great united nation, a republic founded on 
principles that shall carry it along 'til the end of time. Thirty 
millions in the 60's are an himdred millions today. The United 
States, a fourth rate power then, is in the front rank now, and 
your Uncle Sam in the Parliament of the world occupies a 
front seat, coequal with all the monarchs of the earth." 

An eloquent benediction by Rev. Dr. R. H. McKim fol- 
lowed, and the audience dispersed while the band played "The 
Star-Spangled Banner." 



39 




COL. HILARY A.HERBERT 

MA5TER0FCEREM0NIE5 



CHAPTER IV. 

The Unveiling. 

The Confederate Section is on the highest level of the 
National Cemetery at Arlington. The graves of the Con- 
federate dead surrounding the monument are all marked by 
marble headstones of uniform size. The trees with which 
the plot is ornamented, though flourishing, are still small and 
the spot is therefore in full view of the Washington Monu- 
ment, less than a mile away across the P'otomac, there, on the 
4th of June, 1914, the unveiling took place. The grounds 
had been elaborately and beautifully decorated with Union 
and Confederate flags and with flowers from the White 
House, patriotic organizations and Washington Conserva- 
tories. Distinguished guests from far and near, statesmen, 
judges, representatives of the Army and Navy, veterans. 
Confederate and Federal, and an immense number of entitled 
citizens had come as guests of the Daughters of the Con- 
federacy, who were present in large numbers, when the fol- 
lowing program w^as carried out : 



^ragramm^ 



Prngrammp uf tl|p Hlnuriliuij of ll)t Arlingtnu (Uimfpli- 

pratp IHmumtpnt, Arlington. Btnitnia, 

Sl^nrfitiay, 3nnp 4, 1914. 

3 r m. 

MRS. DAISY McLAURIN STEVENS, President-General. Presiding 

COL. HILARY A. HERBERT, Master of Ceremonies 

CAPT. JOHN H. HICKEY COL. JOHN J. CLEM 

Marshals of the Day 

Musical Program given by the Fifth Cavalry Band 
William J. Cain, Band Master 

1. Grand Selection — "Southern Airs." Conterno 

2. Invocation Dr. Randolph IT. McKim 

41 



3. Address General Bennett H. Young 

Commander-in-Chief, U. C. V. 

4. Address General Washington Gardner 

Commander-in-Chief , G. A. R. 

5. Cornet Solo The Holy City 

6. Address Col. Robert E. Lee 

7. Address Col. Hilary A. Herbert 

Bugle Call 

8. Unveiling of Monument Paul Micou 

Grandson of Col. Hilary A. Herbert 

9. Salute— 21 guns Battery of Artillery 

10. Introduction of the Sculptor Sir Moses Ezekiel 

11. Presentation of Monument to the United States, 

Mrs. Daisy McLaurin Stevens 
President-General United Daughters of the Confederacy 

12. Address The President of the United States 

13. "My Country, 'Tis of Thee" I t-c.x n ^ tj a 

■' , , -n. „ > Fifth Cavalry Band 

"Star Spangled Banner j 

14. Placing of Floral Tributes 

15. Benediction - Rev. Andrew R. Bird 

16. Decoration, Tomb of Unknown Union Dead 

Mr. Wallace Streater. 

When the tones of the sweet music given by the band had 
ceased and the hum of the vast audience had hushed. Rev. Dr. 
Randolph H. McKim pronounced the following invocation : 

"O God, without whom nothing is strong, nothing is holy, 
we invoke Thy presence and benediction upon the exercises 
of this hour. Let Thy blessing rest on all that is said and 
done here to-day. Come down from the throne of Thy holi- 
ness and Thy glory, and hallow this spot to us and to our 



42 



children forever. May we feel the good hand of our God 
upon us as we dedicate this memorial of the valor and virtue 
of our comrades in arms. 

"Blessed be Thy Name for the zeal and devotion of the 
women of the South, through which the building of this monu- 
ment has been achieved. Blessed be Thy Name, that, as Thou 
did'st endue Bazaleel, the Son of Uri, with the spirit of wis- 
dom and understanding to devise skilful works in brass for 
the Mosaic Tabernacle, so Thou hast, in our day, anointed Thy 
servant Ezekiel with a like skill for the fashioning of this 
monument. 

"Grant, O Lord, that this enduring bronze may speak to the 
generations to come of the intense love of liberty that animated 
our brothers who fought and fell under the banner of the 
Southern Cross. May it be a perpetual reminder of their un- 
c[uenchable valor — of their lofty patriotism — of their heroic 
constancy — of their unswerving loyalty — of their splendid re- 
sponse to the stern call of duty — of their patient endurance 
of every hardship — of their unfaltering courage in every danger 
— of the exalted spirit of self-sacrifice with which they gave 
themselves to the defense of their homes and their firesides. 

"Blessed be Thy name that we are now able to recognize 
that their valor and their devotion were not in vain — that 
their heroic blood was not shed to no purpose. Though their 
banner sank in defeat, we believe, O Lord, that they won a 
sublime moral victory, whose luster will never grow dim. 
They have left us an immortal heritage of glory which can 
never be taken from us. May we and those who come after 
us, read aright the lesson of their unselfish devotion. Though 
dead, yet let them speak to us ! Let their example of courage 
and self-sacrifice and loyalty to conscience, be a perpetual in- 
spiration to the young men of our country. North and South, 
in generations to come ! Let our children, and our children's 
children, as they stand before this memorial of the Confed- 
erate Soldier, have borne in upon their spirits the sublime 
truth that fidelity is better than success, and that, though the 
patriot's banner may go down in disaster, and he himself may 
perish, yet his memory and his example will remain a benedic- 
lion to his people. 

43 



"So may it be, O God of Truth and Grace, with the memory 
of these, our comrades ! May it shine as the stars, with a 
deathless Hght, above the sordid and selfish aims of men! 
May it inspire Americans in the years to come with an aim as 
high and as pure as theirs, to suffer, to dare, and to die, not 
for fame or for reward, not for place or for power, not lured 
by ambition or goaded by necessity, but in simple obedience 
to duty as God shall give them to see it. And as the blue 
and the gray mingle their dust on this consecrated hill, may 
the men of the North and the men of the South join hands 
and hearts in the labors and sacrifices which must be under- 
taken in the years to come, for the honor, the happiness and 
the glory of our country. 

"Grant, also, O Lord, that this monument may stand as a 
perpetual memorial of the reconciliation between the people 
of the States once arrayed against each other in deadly con- 
flict. Let it stand as the embodiment of the high and pure 
ideals of the Confederate Soldier, who fought, not for con- 
quest, or for glory, but for the sacred right of self-govern- 
ment. Let it stand as a witness to their valor, and as a pledge 
that the men of the South in the generations to come will 
emulate their superb courage and their whole-hearted devotion, 
should any foreign foe assail the Republic. 

"O Son of God, and Prince of Peace, our help in ages past, 
cur hope for years to come, we bless Thee that the spirit of 
brotherly love has been poured out upon our people, and that 
men who once met in wrath on the field of battle meet here 
today as friends and brothers in the great enterprises of 
peace. 

"We who fought for Southern Independence bow reverently, 
O Lord, to Thy Divine Will. Henceforth, we pray and labor 
for the good and the glory of our reunited country. We have 
beat our swords into ploughshares, and our spears into pruning 
hooks. Ours it shall be to strive in fraternal emulation with 
our Northern brothers, in all undertakings for the common 
weal. Use us most gracious God, survivors by Thy mercy of 
the Confederate Army — use us and our children, — yea, use 
the whole Southern people, as co-workers with Thyself in ful- 

44 



Ijlling the bright designs of Thy Providence for this great 
Republic and for the Anglo-Saxon race. 

"And now, O Lord, our heavenly Father, the high and mighty 
Ruler of the universe, we pray Thee to bless our whole land, 
and all our people. Pardon our sins. Lead us in the paths 
of righteousness and justice. Give peace in our time, we 
beseech Thee, O Lord. And especially we pray that Thou 
wilt bless Thy servant, the President of the United States. 

"Strengthen his hand, and his heart for the great tasks en- 
trusted to him. Give him a right judgment in all the difificult 
problems that he must face. Anoint him with wisdom and 
courage for his solemn responsibilities. 

"These and all other blessings of Thy Providence and Thy 
Grace, we humbly ask in the name and through the merits of 
our Lord and Savior Jesus Christ, Amen." 



Colonel Herbert here introduced General Bennett H. 
Young, Commander of the United Confederate Veterans, who 
spoke as follows: 

"Forty and nine years ago Divine Providence furled the 
Confederate banner, and with it shrouded a young Nation's 
life and hopes ; but sacred memories abide in the Southern 
heart, while the bravery and chivalry, the daring and the 
doing, from Sumter to Appomattox, have challenged the gaze 
and evoked the admiration of both the nearer and the farther 
world. The young Nation perished, but poetry and pathos, 
honor and heroism, inspiration and lesson, linger in the golden 
urn tha,t hol/ds it^ cherished ashes. An immortal crown is its 
heritage of defeat and death. 

"For ages to come the story of the valor of the men who 
fought from 1861 to 1865, on both sides, will stir the patriot- 
ism and quicken the pride of the American people. Money 
can not buy heroism. It can not create standards. Lives of 
courage — -men broad-breasted, like gates of brass and mighty 
thewed with faith and conviction — alone can make lofty ideals, 
create high aspirations, inspire noble thoughts, incite boldest 
action, and cause a people to lift its eye to those heights where 

45 



stars shine and comets come and go. Not bonds and stocks, 
not lands and things, but those topless characters which live 
the truth and die for the right make the human heart beat 
quick, and a nation's career resplendent with deeds and illus- 
trious with fame. 

"Today we have come together- — ^Blue and Gray — to dedicate 
a Monument, and empty a goblet upon that federal soil be- 
neath which sleeps a number of Confederate dead. If the 
world's most learned and profound student of history could 
stand on the towers that overlook the battlefield of Gettys- 
burg, and catch from its blood-stained soil, the echoes of death 
and wounding which fifty-one years ago were witnessed there, 
and be asked if the happenings of this afternoon were pos- 
sible, he would quickly declare such things to be inconceivable. 

"If he should move southward and take his place on Lookout 
Mountain with its heights lifted above the clouds, and catch 
the murmurings that come up from the rippling currents of 
'Chickamauga Creek,' ages ago christened by the Red Man 
'The Stream of Death,' and read from the records of the 
past the ghastly story of Snodgrass Hill and its 25,000 
of wounded and dead in its thickets and on its hillsides in 
September, 1863, and then be inquired of whether the men 
who were there and so fiercely and desperately fought, could, 
half a century later, stand in this, the Nation's greatest mili- 
tary burying place, and see men from both armies unite in 
dedicating a monument to Confederate dead, he would cry out 
with fierce emphasis, 'Such an occurrence is not only unbe- 
lievable, but preposterous.' 

"If he should go still further west, and take his place in the 
Government park at Shiloh, on the fateful field of April, 1862, 
where Albert Sidney Johnston gave his magnificent life for the 
Southland, and with the pictures on his brain of the tremen- 
dous mortality and indescribable suft'ering that filled those 
ravines where 110,000 men so vehemently and furiously con- 
tended for mastery, and be asked if the ceremonies of this 
hour could ever be — if asked whether the men from both 
armies who fought in that conflict would ever assemble for 
unveiling a Confederate memorial under the very shadow of 

46 



the dome of the Nation's Capitol, commemorating the heroism 
and courage of the men on the Southern side, he would ex- 
claim : 'An event like that can never happen.' 

"If such a seer had the mystical lore and the prophetic 
knowledge that the evening of life brings to the wisest of 
men, he would have no ken that would enable him to catch 
the full conception of the justice and reasonableness of the 
mind and heart of a nation, which has felt the impulse and 
the power that come from the uplifting forces of a Republic, 
where there stands as the real keystone of the arch of liberty 
the greatest of all formulated political truths, "Equality be- 
fore the Law." 

"Men who hold the inalienable right of suffrage, enlarged 
and strengthened by universal education, feel strong personal 
responsibility for the policy and government of the land they 
claim for their home, and they grow broad in their judg- 
ments and just in their conclusions. 

"There have been so many surprises in the life and career of 
our Republic, that thoughtful men are ever looking out for 
the extraordinary and unusual. Nothing more strange and 
unwonted has ever happened in national life than the exer- 
cises of this afternoon. Its happening marks another step in 
the complete elimination of sectional passions, suspicions, or 
prejudice. This monument is a history, a pledge, and a proph- 
ecy: as a history, it memorializes the devotion of a people to 
a cause that was lost ; as a pledge, it gives assurance that 
North and South have clasped hands across a fratricidal grave ; 
as a prophecy, it promises a blessed future in which sectional 
hate shall be fully transmuted into fraternity and good will. 

"As one looks around in this Federal cemetery he can but 
question if the exercises of this hour are real, or if they be but 
the phantom of some dreamer's imagination. We are here to 
dedicate on the Nation's ground, on the space reserved for its 
most renowned and illustrious dead, a Confederate monument. 
In its inception, its construction, its location, and in its mis- 
sion, this structure stands in a class by itself. 

"It has been said, and it is probably true, that there are 
more monuments erected to commemorate Confederate valor 



47 



and sacrifice than were ever built to any cause, civil, political, 
or religious. Whether this be correct or not, it can be asserted 
without possible contradiction, that in proportion to popula- 
tion, the Confederate states have more memorials to their dead 
ihan any kingdom or commonwealth that has ever maintained, 
or sought to create, a national life. A Republic alone could 
foster, or permit those who lost in a great, prolonged struggle, 
to erect in such a place as this a tribute to the dead, who for 
four years battled against the flag that floats above a place 
of sepulture like this. 

"The past half century has softened and removed the asperi- 
ties of the American war. It has blotted out the real bitter- 
ness of conflict. It has created a transcendent patriotism by 
according survivors full liberty in dealing with the past of 
those who on either side took part in its campaigns. 

"At this hour I represent the survivors of the Southern army. 
Though this Confederate monument is erected on Federal 
ground, which makes it unusual and remarkable, yet the men 
from whom I hold commission would only have me come 
without apologies or regrets for the past. Those for whom 
1 speak gave the best they had to their land and country. They 
spared no sacrifice and no privation to win for the Southland 
national independence. 
/ "I am sure that I shall not offend the proprieties of either 
the hour or the occasion when I say that we still glory in the 
records of our beloved and immortal dead. The dead, for 
Vvdiom this monument stands sponsor, died for what they be- 
lieved to be right. Their surviving comrades and their chil- 
dren still believe, that that for v/hich they suffered and laid 
down their lives was just — that their premises in the civil 
war were according to our Constitution. The men of the 
Confederacy submit, but they have no words to recall nor his- 
tory to change. They are unwilling to depreciate aught of 
'^-^ the sacrifices of the Confederate people. The South gave 
200,000 lives, the best and most precious offering it had, as an 
assurance of honesty of conviction, unfaltering faith, and in- 
tegrity of purpose. 

"The sword said the South was wrong, but the sword is not 



48 



necessarily guided by conscience and reason. The power of 
numbers and the longest guns can not destroy principle, nor 
obliterate truth. Right lives forever. It survives battles, 
failures, conflicts and death. There is no human power, how- 
ever mighty, that can in the end annihilate truth. 

"To accept a situation the sword created, and bow gracefully 
and promptly to the inevitable decrees of force, is one of the 
highest evidences of great manhood and superb valor. 

"When Robert E. Lee, at Appomattox, conceded defeat, and 
advised his tired, hungry, ragged followers to accept the or- 
derings of a relentless destiny, and to assume without mental 
reservation or reluctance the duties and obligations of Ameri- 
can citizens, and begin anew the struggle for support of them- 
selves and their families, and to aid in building up the gov- 
ernment they had so bravely fought, he reached not only the 
apex of human greatness, but also of human courage. 

"No man can stand on this hill and look southward, without 
feeling his heart glow with wonder and admiration and pride, 
as he reviews what the soldiers of the Army of the Potomac 
and the Army of Northern Virginia wrought out in heroism 
and valor between Arlington and Richmond. The skill of the 
leaders, the patience, perseverance and valor of the soldiers 
on both sides, have crowned the American volunteer with a 
history that will brighten as centuries come and go. 

"Less than 300 Confederates have found their last resting 
place about the monument that will shortly be unveiled. There 
were no men of high rank among the sleepers, but they were 
none the less heroes for lack of badges of authority. The 
noblest dead are not always the men who held the offices. The 
most heroic men in the Confederate army were the men who 
carried the guns. They marched, they starved, they suffered, 
they hungered, and they fought many great battles, but they 
never complained. They were brave and loyal, hopeful and 
courageous to the end. They never faltered in their fidelity 
to country and duty. 

"We are almost in sight of the spot where General Lee wit- 
nessed the most wonderful evidence of devotion and loyalty 
that ever came into the life of a commander. History tells of 

49 



nothing grander in all its annals. In the desperate struggle at 
and about Spottsylvania Court House, three times the Con- 
federate chieftain started to the front, in apparent crises, to 
lead his legions. Three times, these men, who never quailed 
before any foe, and who had never grounded their arms in the 
face of any odds, stood still in their ranks exposed to a wither- 
mg storm of shot and shell, and refused to go forward one 
itep until General Lee had removed himself from immediate 
danger. Above the din and crash of the cannons' roar and the 
muskets' flash, was heard from these men of Texas, Georgia, 
Maryland, Florida, Virginia, Louisiana, the Carolinas, Ala- 
bama, Tennessee, Mississippi, the cry: "General Lee to the 
rear! General Lee to the rear!" It was not only the shout 
of protest ; it was the voice of love. Every man refused to 
lift a gun, or to advance an inch, until their beloved leader 
obeyed their tender but firm demand. There was no man in 
that army who would not have given his own life to have 
spared a wound or harm to Robert E. Lee. At the last, when 
.John B. Gordon, with that voice which thrilled and enthused 
all who heard it either in peace or in war, with a distinctness 
that rose above the discord of battle, cried out: "General Lee, 
these men have never failed you before, and they will not fail 
you now, but they will not advance until you go to the rear," 
General Lee rode away, and the Confederates, who forced him 
to a safer position redeemed their promise, and compelled 
their enemies to retire. 

"Mr. Chairman, some of those who spoke at that fateful mo- 
ment that message of love and devotion, now sleep in this 
circle. There are some here who climbed up the heights of 
Gettysburg and wrote in their blood upon its pitiless rocks the 
story of Southern manhood. 

"Some of those, who here rest under the shadow of this beau- 
tiful monument, were at Sharpsburg, and Fredericksburg, and 
Cold Harbor, and there stood unmoved and unblailched in a 
storm of shot and shell, that was so fierce that it eliminated 
hope for the instant from the hearts of all who witnessed 
those scenes of havoc and desolation. 

"There are some here who rode with Stuart at Fleetwood 



50 



Hill, and saw Ashby die. Those who are here were made of 
the same stuff as the Virginia boy, who, finding his shoes, 
which had lately been brought over from England by block- 
ade, pinching his feet as he climbed Gulp's Hill, calmly sat 
down and remo\'ing them tied them together, strung them 
over his arm, and, barefooted, with his shoes dangling at his 
side, went down in the forefront of the last charge. 

"There are men sleeping here, who have the same spirit as 
the brave lad on the Arkansas River, who, marching with 
General Shelby to surprise and attack a gunboat, took his 
coat from his back to lessen the rumble of the wheels of the 
artillery that was stealthily and silently moving to find die 
Federal enemy, but realizing that his coat was not enough, 
took his only shirt and bound it around the spindles of the 
moving gun, and, with his brawny arms and sturdy chest un- 
covered, marched on. His commander, observing his spirit 
and sacrifice, promised him half a dozen shirts when the battle 
was over, but when the conflict was ended he needed no gar- 
ment. He found a grave with not even a blanket to protect 
liis wan face, or cover his pale hands that were folded across 
his stilled bosom, when he was laid away in a trench on that 
battlefield which his courage had helped to make glorious. 

"To understand the spirit that animated the heroes that this 
monument commemorates, we must get some idea of what they 
were, of the timber of which they were made. After all, war 
is not an unmixed evil. Wars of necessity create standards 
of courage and manhood, that inspire men hundreds of years 
after the actors have disappeared from the conflict. The men 
who fought on both sides, everybody now concedes, believed 
they were fighting for principle. They looked at the Nation's 
rights from different angles, but they were willing to die for 
the truth as it appeared to their vision. This is why so large 
a number of men fell under their respective standards on the 
battlefield. Eleven out of every hundred men that enlisted 
in the Confederate army perished under the Confederate flag 
in the storm of conflict. Four and seventy-five one hundredths 
of the men who enlisted in the Federal army likewise died 
under the national emblem. No such percentage of men ever 

51 



laid down their lives in any war under their standards in 
battle. 

"When the youth of this country understand and appreciate 
these figures, the fidelity they signify, then must come into 
their minds a fervor and an intensity of patriotism, that will 
make a superb citizenship, and give to the American Republic 
those elements which must raise it to highest rank among the 
world's nations. 

"The men buried here represent all the men who wore the 
gray. Tlie glories of the Confederate armies are a common 
heritage of the South, and these beautiful and attractive memo- 
rials stand as a tribute to all who followed the stars and bars. 
The record of the Confederate armies, from the Atlantic to 
the Rio Grande, is a common fund of glory, which endures 
for the benefit of all, however humble, who shared in the 
service that won its renown and created its fame. 

"True patriotism does not require that either the North or 
South should give up its ideals. Are they not stronger and 
better for each maintaining its devotion to the history and 
achievements of those who fought? The South is none the 
less patriotic because it had as its ideals Lee, Jackson, the 
Johnstons, Kirby Smith, Breckinridge, Stuart, Hampton, the 
■Tills, Bragg, Polk, Hardee, Forrest, Wheeler, Green, Marma- 
duke. Shelby, and thousands of other defenders, who gave 
it all that there was of greatness and worth in human 
character. Some think they were mistaken in judgment; all 
know they were devoted to conscience and conviction. 

"There are no surviving Confederates, and none who svmpa- 
thize with them, that would care to lessen the estimate that 
the North put on men like General Grant and those who 
wrought with him. There is glory enough on both sides to 
fill any Nation with pride in their triumphs and labors. North 
and South, there were great actors, and what they did and 
what they dared will inspire and thrill the people, and create 
loftiest patriotic devotion in the men and women of America 
for all ages to come. The United States need not go to other 
lands for heroes. There is an unlimited supply at home. 

"The Confederates can never forswear their flag. It repre- 

52 



sents that which is most sacred to them. Those who followed 
it — the blood which coursed through their veins bore upon its 
crimson tides the embellishing glory of a noble ancestry, and 
the performances of their hands they have bequeathed, for 
lesson and inspiration, to all this United Commonwealth. 

"The survivors of either army can not remain very much 
longer. Speeding years bring shortening steps, wrinkled faces, 
and decrepit limbs. Soon the last actor in the civil drama 
will be below the sod, and history and story, poetry and song, 
sculpture and art, will be left to immortalize their names, and 
preach their sermons to generations to come. 

" 'Year by year they're growing older, 
Year by year they're marching slower. 
Year by year the lilting music 

vStirs the hearts of older men. 
Year by year the flag above them 
Seems to bend and bless and love them 
As if grieving for the future 

When they'll never march again. 
Yes, the shores of life are shifting. 

Every year ; 
And we are starward drifting, 

Every year; 
Old places, changing, fret us ; 
The living more forget us ; 
There are fewer to regret us, 

Every year. 

But the truer life draws nigher. 

Every year ; 
And its morning star climbs higher. 

Every year : 
Earth's hold on us grows slighter. 
And the heavy burden lighter. 
And the Dawn Immortal brighter. 

Every year.' 

"All the South thanks you, Mr. Chairman, and your asso- 
ciates, for this magnificent testimonial to its soldiers and its 
cherished Cause. We are glad that this monument is the 
product, not only of a great artist, but of one who wore the 

53 



gray, one who proudly and justly claims a share in the renown 
of the men who followed its adored standard. 

"We rejoice to see these last days, the great days when men 
are big enough and broad enough and wise enough and pat- 
triotic enough, for their country's good and for their country's 
glory, to blot out every trace of bitterness or of unjustness, 
and while ignoring and forgetting none of the memories of 
the past, to look forward with transcendent visions of the fu- 
ture splendor of our common country. Thank God, in doing 
so we sacrifice nothing of our loyalty to the glory of the past. 
We simply lock arms with our fellow citizens in faith and 
hope for the accomplishment of the great work Providence 
has assigned a free people under the impulses of a popular 
government. 

"We are glad that this hour has come, Mr. Chairman. It 
witnesses the full consummation of your task. It is fragrant 
of that which is heroic and grand. Forty thousand survivors 
of Confederate armies appreciate the beauty of this Monvi- 
ment, and say "Amen" to the splendid message of fraternity 
and good-will spoken by this scene today. To posterity, the 
South bequeaths the story of how 600,000 of the pride and 
flower of her sons struggled with the awful enginery of horrid 
war, to maintain her political faith and integrity. May the 
hands that fought be the hands that clasp, and the hearts that 
bled be the hearts that rejoice!" 



Gener.vl Washington Gardner, Commander-in-Chief of 
the G. A. R., was introduced and spoke as follows : 

"It seems fitting that here in this place and on these grounds, 
once the home of Robert E. Lee, there should rest the remains 
of some of the gallant men who followed that great soldier 
even unto death. It is fitting here, in sight of the Nation's 
Capital, and in this vast burial plot consecrated to American 
valor that some of our fellow-countrymen, the representatives 
of once hostile armies whose unsurpassed bravery is now a 
common heritage and pride, should rest in undisturbed slum- 

54 



ber, and that the place of final sepulture should be under the 
supervision and care of the National Government. 

"The presence of the Chief Magistrate of the Nation, Mem- 
bers of his Cabinet, and of others high in the councils of the 
Government with that of representatives from every section of 
the country, participating in these dedicatory exercises serve 
to illustrate anew that the sectional bitterness and hate long 
preceding and which culminated in the great war no longer 
fmd a place in the hearts nor expression upon the lips of our 
countrymen. 

"Monuments of whatever enduring material are the visible 
expression of appreciation, of gratitude, or of affection. A 
monumentless people is either a people without a history or 
else a people without a heart. 

"This memorial structure speaks the language of peace and 
good-will. It says to all who come hither and read the super- 
scription that the swords and bayonets that once gleamed along 
the battle's fiery front have been 'beaten into plowshares and 
pruning hooks.' It declares through the symbolical wreath 
of unfading laurel held in outstretched hand above the sleeping 
dead that the spirit of heroic devotion and lofty self-sacrifice 
which they manifested is held in grateful and affectionate 
memory. 

"There is room in the hearts of the people of all the land for 
cherished recollections of the valorous dead and, at the same 
time, for the most unfaltering love and loyalty and devotion 
to the Union of all the States. Without the existence of the 
former we should be disposed to doubt the sincerity or stead- 
fastness of the latter. 

"In the perspective of the receding years, the war looms in 
increasing proportions along the national horizon. Its great 
and beneficent results now everywhere recognized are grad- 
ually settling into the abiding convictions of all intelligent 
men. For full eighty years the system of government founded 
by our fathers was regarded by many as an experiment. 
Doubting patriots at home and vmfriendly critics abroad fore- 
told the coming certain dissolution of the L'nion. With much 
show of reason they declared our government rested upon an 



o:d 



insecure foundation. The recognized fundamental weakness 
was a constant menace to the permanency of the superstructure. 
Prior to the war, the existence of this weakness had with por- 
tentous threatenings repeatedly manifested itself both in the 
North and the South. In the light of the past the war for the 
preservation of the Union and for the settlement by the arbitra- 
ment of arms of the great constitutional question involved 
seemed inevitable. In that stupendous conflict neither side 
will ever have to apologize for the sincerity or the devotion 
of its adherents. 

"When the battle clouds lifted and the light of peace shone 
in ; when the people had again become settled in their wonted 
avocations and dispassionately surveyed the results, it was 
found that the menace which had so long disturbed the tran- 
quility of the people and threatened the existence of the Union 
had been forever removed. It was found that the fundamental 
issues involved had been irrevocably settled and that the foun- 
dation stones upon which the Republic rested had been ce- 
mented anew by the shed blood of our countrymen from the 
North and from the South. Now, we are indeed "an inde- 
structible Union of indestructible States." We are in very 
truth, "a government of the people, by the people, and for 
the people," resting on an enduring foundation. As the fast 
vanishing lines of the surviving Federal and Confederate sol- 
diers marching side by side in peace and amity enter the twi- 
light in the fading afterglow of life's long day, soon to be 
forever lost to mortal sight, of one thing we may rest assured, 
and that is, that whenever and wherever in future the battle 
line is drawn, there will be found the sons of these heroic 
lathers and of their scarcely less heroic mothers, standing side 
by side, shoulder to shoulder, in defense of the Union and 
for the perpetuity of the government founded by our fathers. 

"The contemplation of a glorious past stirs the blood in an 
hour like this, while the thought of a limitless future with all 
its possibilities, its hopes and fears, beckons our countrymen 
to the discharge of every duty and fidelity to every trust in 
peace even as the fathers were vigilant and faithful in war." 



56 



Col. Robert E. Lee, grandson of General R. E. Lee, was 
here introduced and spoke as follows : 

"One of the greatest orators of the South has told us, that: 
'When the Athenian orator of old ascended the rostrum to 
address the popular assembly of Athens he was wont, first 
to offer up the prayer to the immortal gods that no unworthy 
word might escape his lips.' How much more should I today, 
painfully conscious of my inability to meet the task before 
me, humbly pray the true God that no unworthy word should 
fall from me on this holy occasion. 

"There is no firmer foundation for the hopes of the Nation 
than the Confederate Monument at Arlington. It is a Con- 
federate Monument. Raised by the glorious women of the 
South, designed by one of the boy heroes of New Market, 
built on the Herculean pillars, 'the learning of the wise, the 
justice of the great, the prayers of the good, and the valor 
of the brave ;' it commemorates the deathless deeds of the 
Confederate Soldier. 

" 'On this green bank by this fair stream 
We set to-day a votive stone, 
That memory may his deeds redeem 
When, like our sires, our sons are gone.' 

"W^e are not concerned today with deducing lessons from the 
war; nor are we agitated over justifications or vindications, 
the truth wherever found has been bravelv asserted, and: 

" 'Today they stand. 

These martial chiefs in fields afar 
And read the right or wrong of war, 
From God's owm hands ; 
God who lights the stars o'er heights 
Where fame and victory meet, 
God, who lights the stars that shine 
O'er valleys of defeat.' 

"But we come to rejoice that nowdiere, except in our own 
country, could such a scene as this be witnessed. 

"As we stand in this sainted campground of the dead, the 
days of doubt and dread of '61 to '65 live again, for a moment 

57 



in the sublime unity of their anguish, and their history passes 
before us in a great panoramic review. We see two great 
armies introduced on the plains of Manassas, witness them 
trying each other's mettle for three days in the hills of Penn- 
sylvania, watch them in a death grapple in the tangled wilder- 
ness, and wonder as they separate forever at Appomattox. 
There was wafted from the North on the breezes of that 
April day the patriotic prayer, "Let us have peace." There 
came back from the South, strong and clear, on the startled 
air the Divine notes of hope. 'God disposes, let this satisfy 
us.' 'Human fortitude should be equal to human adversity.' 
'AH good citizens must unite in honest efforts to obliterate 
the effects of the war, and to restore the blessings of peace. 
They must not abandon their country, but go to work and 
build up its prosperity.' 'The young men especially must 
stay at home, bearing themselves in such a manner as to gain 
the esteem of every one, at the same time they maintain their 
own respect." 'It should be the object of all to avoid con- 
troversy, to allay passion, and give scope to every kindly feel- 
ing.' 'True patriotism sometimes requires of men to act 
exactly contrary at one period to that which it does at another, 
and the motive that impels them, the desire to do right, is 
precisely the same. * * *' Thus the South stopped fight- 
ing, not another 'shot did she fire; but closed her lips, saluted 
fate, and from the chivalry of war enlisted in the chivalry of 
labor,' and there will be found no word in her vocabulary, 
nor act in her demeanor inconsistent with the peace, progress 
and perpetuity of a reunited country. 

"W'e live in a wonderful age, and in a great country are words 
so often heard that we fail to appreciate their true meaning. 
It was America who announced in the time of the Revolution 
that there would be no taxing without the consent of the 
taxed ; it was for her to discover in the Constitution Construc- 
tion period a new theory in Political Science. The Constitu- 
tion, the creator of the Body Politic, is supreme. Government, 
the creature of the Bodv Politic, is subordinate ; and as the 
result of the war, none but she could have exhibited, for the 
admiration and wonder of the world, and the guarantee of the 
stability of Representative Government, the Great American 

58 



Paradox, a quarrel in which both sides were right : the North 
had no doubt about her position, and the South knew she was 
right. Strange spectacle this, that even the sledge hammer 
of time could have welded such diametrically opposed posi- 
tions, and yet not strange when we consider the justice, pa- 
triotism and greatness of the whole American people. 

"All that is asked is, that the Confederate Soldier be known. 
It can be said of him, as a class, as a distinguished Boston 
author said of one of them, that he started to study the career 
of this soldier as a critic, and he ended by loving him. Those 
who faced him on the firing line, and those to whom he has 
been revealed by the searchlight of true history, have never 
failed to admire him. Gen. Chas. A. Whittier of the Union 
Army says : 'The Confederate Army will deserve to rank as 
the best which has existed on this continent.' General Piatt 
of the same service tells us 'How these rebels fought the world 
never knew. For two years they kept back an army that girt 
their borders, with a fire that shriveled our forces as they 
march in like tissue paper in a flame. * * * ^Y[q North- 
ern Army had more killed than the Confederate Generals had 
in command.' General Hooker observes 'that army has 
* * * acquired a character for steadiness and efficiency 
unsurpassed, in my judgment, in ancient or modern times. 
We have not been able to rival it.' The Hon. Chas. Francis 
Adams, whose generosity and breadth of views have placed 
him a century ahead of his time, says, 'I doubt if a hostile 
force of an equal size ever advanced into an enemy's country, 
or fell back from it in retreat, leaving behind less cause of 
hate and bitterness than the Army of Northern Virginia in 
that memorable campaign which culminated at Gettysburg,' 
and the great Federal Commander's desire is 'for perpetual 
peace and harmony with an enemy whose manhood * * * 
drew forth such Herculean deeds of valor.' Oh "Johnny 
Reb" what a noble army praise thee. There is nothing here 
imworthy of the highest ideals of American manhood. There 
is no lowering of standards. There is no trailing of banners 
in the dust of despair. There is no sinking in the quagmire 
of disgrace and dishonor. These are men 'for Nations to 

59 



trust and reverence, and for heroes and ruler to copy.' These 
men march down the high road of history with a swing of 
\ictory and there is emblazoned on their banners the ancient 
proverb, 'There is no Conquerer but God.' Now we see why 
the soldier President, William McKinley, a son of Ohio, he 
delighted to call himself the grandson of Old Virginia, the 
great pacificator, who did more to bring about 'the era of 
good feeling' than any other President of his day, he was 
big enough to see across the Potomac and great enough to 
become the President of the whole country. We now begin 
to appreciate why he inaugurated, and a Country's Congress 
authorized, the movement which we crown to-day with ever- 
lasting bronze. It is meet and right, and the custom will be 
observed as long as the last old soldier lives, that the North 
should honor her sons as Federal Soldiers, and the South should 
place her wreath of memory's sweet immortelles on the vener- 
able brow of gray, but when we come on the Nation's soil, we 
hail them both as Americans. Captain Cecil Battine, of the 
English Army, speaking of them both in this connection, says : 
'The Americans still hold the world's record for hard fight- 
ing.' Thus the South places the Confederate Soldiers as one of 
the brightest jewels in the diadem that encircles the Nation's 
brow to shed undying luster on American arms. 

"In the time of peace we find the sons of the South occupy- 
ing the highest positions in the land in all departments. A 
very distinguished gentleman. Southern born, is in the White 
House. The young men of the South are wearing the red 
badge of courage in the Nation's ranks. Dear old Dixie has 
become a national anthem. Under yonder dome there sits a 
Confederate Soldier at the head of the highest tribunal this 
side of Heaven. 

"As we loiter in the precious precincts of an old Southern 
home, we hear the last voices of a civilization such as the 
world will never see again, dying through the corridors of 
time, as a last sweet note recedes through the recesses of a 
cathedral. There stood around the massive mansions of the 
South live oaks, which timbered the old ship of state and saw 
her through many a tempestuous sea, and there grew under 



60 



their protection, as do sweet violets under the shadow of 
great trees, the fairest and purest womanhood the world has 
or will ever see. True it is that the domestic light of the 
South shone through the dark veil of slavery, hut that dark- 
r.ess was not great ; it was a slavery but not a serfdom, the 
dwelling together of two unequal races, without a familiarity ; 
it was the good old-fashioned patriarchal bond-men and l)ond- 
maids, and not medieval chattels or Roman villeins. These 
old Southern plantations were the realms of the courtly gen- 
tlemen, the home of the contented servant and the kingdom 
of the white woman. If it ever becomes necessary to point 
cut model womanhood all that will be required is to open the 
doors of one of these old Southern homes and behold the true 
woman, enthroned by love, admiration and adoration ; 'her vir- 
tues still smell sweet and blossom in the dust,' and wher- 
ever her hallowed bones lie buried, earth has the care of the 
ashes of one as good and self-sacrificing as any who lay in 
an unmarked grave of an African jungle, having fallen under 
the banner of the cross, or as royal and as regal as those who 
sleep under the spires of Westminster or the dome of St. 
Paul's. 

"We come now to ask the question which the great Law- 
Giver of Israel told his people would be asked of them by 
their children, when they celebrated the Passover in the Prom- 
ised Land — ^' What mean ye by this service ?' It means : 

" 'There is a true glory and a true honor ; the glory of duty 
done, the honor of integrity of principle.' It means : 

"That there burns pure and bright in the heart of the 
Southern woman the celestial fire of love for the Confederate 
soldier. It means : 

" 'That the South is great among the greatest ; and that her 
people are as true and brave a people as ever guarded the 
dust of heroes, or kept pure and bright the vestal fires of 
fame. It means : 

" 'That all the States stand once more under one grand glo- 
rious national emblem 'with a star for every State and a 
State for every star.' 



61 



" 'Your flag and my flag how it flies today 

O'er your land and my land and half the world away, 
Rose red, and blood red, its stripes forever gleam 
Snow white, and soul white, the great forefathers' dream. 
Sky blue and true blue, with stars that beam aright, 
A glorious guidon by the day, a shelter through the night. 
Your flag and my flag and oh, how much it holds 
Your land and my land secure within its folds. 
Your heart and my heart beat quicker at the sight, 
Sun-kissed and wind-tossed, the red, the blue, the white. 
The one flag, the great flag, the flag for me and you. 
Glorified all else beside, the red, the white, the blue.' " 



The Master of Ceremonies, Col. Hilary A. Herbert, then 
spoke as follows : 
"Madam PRKSiDENr-GENERAL : 

"The monument, which, in behalf of your Executive Com- 
mittee and your Committee on Design, I am about to present 
to you is as unique in its origin as it is in design, but I need 
not give you its history ; others have already told it. And 
I shall not attempt to describe it ; when that veil is lifted it 
will speak for itself. 

"A monument to the Confederate dead, it stands here in this 
National Cemetery, alongside of monuments to the Union dead, 
and when you have received it at my hand, you will turn it 
over to the head of the Government against which these Con- 
federates fought, to be cared for by that Government forever ; 
and in that act soldiers against whom these men fought are 
participating. To one unfamiliar with our people and the 
workings of our institutions all this no doubt seems strange, 
and strange, too, he must think it, that in this unveiling you 
should be representing the public sentiment of today in the 
State of Mississippi as faithfully as did that immaculate states- 
man, Jefferson Davis, when he drew tears from his audience 
as he bade farewell to the Senate of the Unite'd States in 1861. 
To Americans this is no miracle; it is the result of natural 
causes — the liberalizing influences of free institutions and of 
modern education ; the unpretentious, but real chivalry of the 
American soldier. Federal and Confederate; foes on the picket 
line saluting, instead of shooting, each other ; men risking life 
in battle to give water to a wounded enemy, or to drag him 

62 



out of the line of fire. Such things as these occurred during 
our war. A living witness is our Marshal of the day, this one- 
legged Confederate soldier here by my side, Capt. Hickey. As 
he lay, wounded and helpless on the field of Corinth, where 
shot and shell were flying fast, a Union soldier, at the risk 
of his own, saved Captain Hickey's life by dragging him 
out of the way of rushing artillery wagons. That Union sol- 
dier is now Congressman Kirkpatrick of Iowa. The memory 
of incidents like this has helped to make possible this monu- 
ment. Since the war we have had from old soldiers hearty 
acknowledgment of each other's purity of motive, patriotism 
and courage ; interchanges between Federal and Confederate 
organizations of courtesies and hospitalities ; speeches like 
those you have just heard from General Young and General 
Gardner and Colonel Lee. The words of such men are golden. 
General Young and General Gardner represent their great or- 
ganizations, because they have proven themselves worthy in 
war and in peace. Colonel Lee's noble words come as an echo 
from our great chieftain who, after winning immortality as a 
soldier, did so much by precept and example to bring about 
the happy conditions of today. 

"But, surveying the whole field, cold reason tells us that 
the chiefest factor in our wonderful coming together as one 
people has been our old Federal Constitution for the preser- 
vation of the fundamental ideas of which both sides were 
fighting. That Constitution rests, and it can exist only, on 
the basis of co-equal self-governing States. That Constitu- 
tion for more than a hundred years has never for a moment, 
either in peace or war, been entirely out of the mind of the 
American people. It secured to them the home-rule their 
ancestors had won in the battles of the Revolution. Even in 
the day of Congressional reconstruction, when Abraham Lin- 
coln, who alone could and would have saved the South from 
that awful calamity, was in his grave, even in that, the mad- 
dest hour the country has ever known. Congress rejected the 
idea of keeping the South in a territorial condition until every- 
thing Southern was educated out of her ; public sentiment, 
even then, demanded that the forms of the Constitution be 
complied with. Entities that had the forms of self-governing 

63 



states were set up. Southern manhood did the rest, converted 
semblance into reahties; the Supreme Court held that the 
States were as indestructible as the Union; it stood lirmly by 
this holding, and the Confederate States were thus enabled to 
eventually regain their places as co-equals with the other 
States under the broad shield of the Constitution. Their 
countrymen, and especially the soldiers of the Union, have 
welcomed the Southern people back into a constitutional 
Union, and here they are today, perfectly content and as virile 
as when, for four years, they kept at bay immensely superior 
numbers of the finest fighters in the world, backed by an in- 
vincible navy. These Southern States are all prospering, every 
element of their population, white and black, and they are not 
only profoundly desirous of peace in the Union which is now 
assured, but of peace with all the world ; and yet, if need be, 
they are ready to stand with their sister States against a 
world in arms. 

"Under our Federal Constitution our country grew to great- 
ness. Under it our prosperity has been absolutely without a 
parallel, in spite of our fratricidal war. To preserve that 
Constitution these soldiers in gray, here at our feet, died ; to 
preserve it those men in blue over there died. There has been 
more blood shed, and more treasure expended, for that instru- 
mlent, than for any and all the charters of government that 
ever were written. It was ordained 125 years ago. There 
have been but six amendments to it, and three of those were 
incident to our war. That our Union under it is to be per- 
petual this monument we unveil today is a token. But today 
there are pending, in the name of Progress, in yonder Capitol, 
over seventy propositions to amend that old Constitution — 
seventy efforts to modify or eliminate some one or more of 
these muniments of life, libertv and property which have stood 
guard over the American people while they were working 
out their wonderful prosperity. God save the Constitution ! 
And God grant that the monument we now unveil may con- 
tribute to the lasting peace and happiness of our country." 



Paul Herbert Micou, the little grandson of Colonel Her- 
bert, then pulled the cord, the veil dropped gracefully, and the 

64 



monument as it appeared in its beautiful proportions, was 
greeted with tremendous applause. 

The blaster of Ceremonies now introduced the artist, Sir 
Moses E'zekiel, who bowed modestly and was greeted with 
prolonged applause. 

A salute of 21 guns, according to the program, was to be 
fired here, but was omitted on account of the approaching 
storm. 



Mrs. Daisy McLaurin Stevens, the President-General, U. 
D. C, then spoke as follows : 

"Behold its glorious beauty, one moment moving us to ec- 
stasies of delight, and again touched by its soulful pathos 
wringing from our eyes tears for the anguish that has been ! 
x\s President-General United Daughters of the Confederacy, 
I would that I could find words to express for our organiza- 
tion the deep gratitude we feel to the Arlington Confederate 
Monument Association of the United Daughters of the Con- 
federacy for their untiring efiforts in harmonious love to give 
for us to the nation this exquisitely magnificent monument, 
wrought by our own, the South's greatest sculptor, Sir Moses 
Ezekiel. Colonel Herbert, in receiving this monument from 
your hands I am not unmindful of the labor of love that has 
been yours, and must needs breathe a prayer to the Great God 
that the sunset rays of the evening of life have lengthened out 
your blessed days that you may praise with us. 

Hail, hail, hail auspicious morning! 
Yon lofty column, reared in air 
To him who made our country great, 
Can almost cast its shadow where 
The victims of a grand despair. 
In long, long ranks of death await 
The last loud trump, the Judgment-Sun, 
Which comes for all, and, soon or late, 
Will come for those at Arlington. 

"Today marks the completion of our seven years of patriotic 
toil. Ours is the rapture born of duty done, of hope deferred 
but at last fulfilled. W^e present to-day this mounment in 
memory of our Confederate dead, though they need no pyra- 



mid to lift them to tlie ages. Though nearly half a hundred 
years have passed since they gave their souls back to the God 
of battles, they are as alive in our hearts and memories as 
when first with glad faces they marched forth to the wild, 
sweet music of war beneath the Stars and Bars. 

"They sleep within the shadow of the home of Lee and in 
sight of the dome of the capitol of their fathers and their 
sons. Above floats the flag they fought, but it does not wave 
above their dust in jeering triumph, but in loving protection. 
It seems to send from each stripe and star benediction upon 
their graves. 

"We have erected to their memory a monument unsurpassed 
in beauty in all the world. But fair and noble as its beauty, 
that beauty is less fair and noble than the lives and deeds of 
those whose memory it proclaims and commemorates. Staunch 
and strong as its enduring bronze were their undaunted hearts. 
Lasting as its material, matched with their memory, it is as 
fading mists of morn on mountain top. 

"In this universe of chance and change, in this world of 
birth and death, nothing material is immortal. Mountains 
sink to level lands, and stars grow cold and die. Great ideas 
and righteous ideals are alone immortal. The eternal years of 
God are theirs. The ideas our heroes cherished were and are 
beneficial as they are everlasting. These were living then, they 
are alive to-day, and shall live to-morrow and work the better- 
ment of mankind. Thus our heroes are of those who, though 
dead, still toil for man, through the arms and brains of those 
their examples have inspired and quickened to nobler things. 

"Across the river stands the Congressional Library, domed 
with gold. Leading American artists were commissioned to 
decorate its marble walls. Their pictures were not only to 
charm the eye with the lure of color and the grace of form, 
but were also to purify the soul and touch the heart by the 
ideals they symbolized and portrayed. 

"None of these frescoes attract more than Alexander's cur- 
tain series illustrating the evolution of the book. In the first 
picture of the series we see half-clad semi-savage men build- 
ing with rough unhewn stones a monument to some dead sea- 
king's life and deeds. From the dawn of time, until the pres- 

66 



ent men and women have built memorials to those they es- 
teemed great, to those whose memories they hoped to per- 
petuate. 

"Dull and hectic reds proclaim upon the pyramids the tri- 
umph of long forgotten kings, but bleeding prisoners walk 
between the chariot wheels. At Rome the Trajan column 
strives to lift unto the stars the buried Caesar's name, but 
around its haggard shaft great trains of captives wind in sculp- 
tured grief, and wring from gazing eyes the sympathetic tear. 
In Paris in their marble Mausoleum at last the ashes of the 
great Napoleon are at rest, in a sarcophagus "fit for a dead 
deity," but the torn and blood-stained banners waving there 
show that his towering throne was built upon the bleeding 
hearts of men. 

"Such monuments mock and sadden each thoughtful heart. 
They hold aloft ideals of force and fraud. They show how 
in a pitiless, mistaken past success could gild a crime. They 
teach that great talent even selfishly used could evoke men's 
applause, and shut the 'gates of mercy on mankind.' 

"But not all monuments are like these. Some are like the 
monument the Daughters of the Confederacy dedicate today. 
They show the future how noble the past has been, and place 
it under bond to prove of equal worth. 

"More than two thousand yeares ago Aeschines standing in 
the Agora of Athens warned the citizens that they would be 
judged by the men they honored. Seven decades since Wen- 
dell Phillips, standing in Boston, said The honors we grant 
mark how we stand.' 

"We of the South accept the test. We are willing to be 
judged by the honors we accord today. All government be- 
fore America's birth rested on the principle that the masses of 
men were unfit to govern themselves. All past government 
had gone upon the idea that certain men were by divine rights 
another's lord. Our fathers believed that the aim of govern- 
ment was not the upholding of the throne of certain kinds, 
not the carrying of banners to unconquered lands, but that the 
sole, legitimate aim was the promotion of the welfare of its 
citizens. Thcv believed there was no treason except dis- 



67 



obedience to duty, no disloyalty except disloyalty to noble 
ideals and institutions nobly won. 

"They had seen these American ideals of self-government 
and freedom of thought not only at home, but they had seen 
them leap the sea and topple down the throne of Bourbon 
kings, in France, and where the Bastile loomed they behold a 
shaft with freedom's statute crowned. 

"They had seen these ideas shake the stolid Englishman from 
his lethargy, and kings and parliament grant an ever widening 
right of suffrage, with ever resultant good. They saw these 
ideals light again in Grecian hearts the fires that burned so 
brightly at Thermopylae and Salamis, and beheld the open- 
ing of the conflict that yet shall cast the Turk across the Syrian 
sea and place the cross of Constantine on Stamboul's towers. 

"They saw these ideas w'orking in the industrial world a 
change yet more marvelous. They saw the human mind un- 
chained at last from restraining fetters, display itself in a 
thousand material conquests. They saw all things that min- 
istered to the comforts and luxuries of the common, greater 
advances made during the seventy years following the procla- 
mation of the Declaration of Independence than had been 
achieved in all the thousand years of the past. Freedom of 
thought, freedom of expression proved, as Jefferson pre- 
dicted, a magic key that opened a thousand doors, where for 
centuries hidden treasures had lain untouched and unknown. 

"Rights so valuable they would not lose. Such rights they 
felt should be prized by all and made everlasting. Strange as 
it may seem, the great mass of soldiers in both armies of the 
war between the States fought for the same ideals. Thus our 
war presents the unique spectacle of men fighting in opposite 
ranks for ideals with like courage and persistence. 

"As they fought for the same ideals, as they each displayed 
courage, as they won immortality of fame, is it not well that 
their dust is laid side by side under the same flag? Is it not 
also well, that to-day their sons and their grandsons are wear- 
ing the same uniform, and not only in America, but in the 
distant islands of the sea are fighting for their fathers form 
of government and their ideals? Is it not also well that the 
representatives of the survivors of both armies are with us 

68 



here to-day? Is it not also well that there comes from the 
White House a President, Southern by birth and breeding 
and Northern by choice of residence and training? 

"It would be both useless and impertinent for me to try to 
praise or appraise our Southern dead. Useless, because the 
world has done and will do that. Soldiers have laid laurels 
on their biers. Divines have quickened listening multitudes to 
nobler things by the recital of their deeds. Poets have em- 
balmed their memory in the honey of immortal verse. It 
would be impertinent, because only lips inspired of God could 
tell how Southern hearts feel unto their Southern dead. 

"And now, Mr. President, I surrender this monument into 
your keeping, and through you to that of the nation. When 
Jefferson was contemplating the Louisiana purchase did he 
think of the material greatness it would add to the Republic? 
Did he think of its mountains breasted with marble and veined 
with gold? Did he think of the living gold of wheat and corn 
that would flash on its bosom, capable of supporting an army 
that could dwarf to nothingness a dream of Ceasar's or Na- 
poleon's? Not so! He said he desired this territory in order 
that it might become the home of happy men and women liv- 
ing under American institutions. Yours, Mr. President, was 
Jefferson's spirit when at ]\Iobile you said the United States 
had no interest in Mexico or any other foreign lands except to 
see that the citizens enjoyed the right to the pursuit of hap- 
piness under a constitutional and just government. As long 
as the Government shall rest in your hands and hands like 
yours, we feel sure i\merican institutions will not pass from 
the earth, and that this monument will be not only a memorial 
of the past, but a symbol of the present and the future. 

"In after years when American boys and girls shall look with 
reverence upon this bronze they shall thank God that they are 
Americans and shall resolve, that whether our flag shall float 
from pole to pole, whether our drum beat circles the sea, at 
least American ideals shall shape the future and the empire 
of civic world be ours." 

As Mrs. Stevens closed her speech, Hon. John Sharp 
Williams, in behalf of the U. D. C. of Mississippi, in a few 
graceful w^ords, presented to her an exquisite bouquet of 

69 



American Beauty roses. These the President General of the 
U. D. C, amid the applause of the audience, graciously pre- 
sented to the President of the United States. 

In reply, the President of the United States said : 
"I assure you that I am profoundly aware of the solemn 
significance of the thing that has now taken place. The 
Daughters of the Confederacy have presented a memorial of 
their dead to the Government of the United States. I hope 
that you have noted the history of the conception of this idea. 
It was suggested by a President of the United States, who 
had himself been a distinguished officer in the Union Army. 
Tt was authorized by an act of Congress of the United States. 
"The corner-stone of the monument was laid during the term 
of a President of the United States, elevated to his high posi- 
tion by the votes of the party which had chiefly prided itself 
upon sustaining the war for the Union, and who, while Secre- 
tary of War, had given authority to erect it. And, now, it has 
fallen to my lot to accept in the name of the great Government, 
which I am privileged for the time to represent, this emblem 
of a reunited people. 

PROUD TO participate 

"I am not so much happy as proud to participate in this 
capacity on such an occasion ; proud that I should represent 
such a people. Am I mistaken, ladies and gentlemen, in sup- 
posing that nothing of this sort could have occurred in any- 
thing but a democracy? The people of a democracy are not 
related to their rulers as subjects are related to a government. 
They are themselves the sovereign, authority, and as they are 
neighbors of each other, quickened by the same passions and 
moved by the same motives, they can understand each other. 

"They are shot through with some of the deepest and pro- 
foundest instincts of human sympathy. They choose their 
governments; they consult their rulers; they live their own 
life, and they will not have that life disturbed and discolored 
by fraternal misunderstandings. I know that a reuniting of 
spirits like this can take place more quickly in our time than 
in any other, because men are now united by an easier trans- 
mission of those influences which make up the foundations 
of peace and of mutual understanding; but no process can 

70 



work these effects unless it is a conducting medium. The 
conducting medium in this instance is the united heart of a 
great people. 

"I am not going to detain you by trying to repeat any of the 
eloquent thoughts which have moved us this afternoon, for I 
rejoice in the simplicity of the task which is assigned to me. 
That task is this, ladies and gentlemen. This chapter in the 
history of the United States is now closed, and I can bid you 
turn with me your faces to the future, quickened by the memo- 
ries of the past, but with nothing to do with the contests of 
the past, knowing as we have shed our blood upon opposite 
sides, we now face and admire one another. 

LEE LISTED AS A GENERAL 

"I do not know how many years ago it was that the Centur}'- 
Dictionary was published, but I remember one day in the Cen- 
tury Cyclopedia of Names I had occasion to turn to the name 
of Robert E. Lee, and I found him there in that book pub- 
lished in New York City, simply described as a great American 
general. 

''The generosity of our judgment did not begin today. The 
generosity of our judgment was made up soon after this great 
struggle was over, when men came and sat together again in 
the Congress and united in all the efforts of peace and of 
government ; and our solemn duty is to see that each one of 
us is in his own consciousness and in his own conduct, a 
replica of this great reunited people. 

"It is our duty and our privilege to be like the country we 
represent, and, speaking no word of malice, no word of criti- 
cism even, standing shoulder to shoulder to lift the burdens 
of mankind in the future and show the paths of freedom to all 
the world." 

The speech of the President was followed and had been 
frequently interrupted by loud applause and this was true of 
all the speeches. From the first word spoken by Gen. Bennett 
Young until the last word that fell from the President the en- 
tire audience of not less than 10,000 people, fully half of them 
standing, were in entire sympathy with the speakers and the 
proceedings were considerably prolonged by the applause that 
interrupted the orators. 

71 



Placing of Flowers. 

After the President's speech came the placing of the many 
beautiful wreaths that had been contributed. The program 
contemplated that ladies previously selected for the purpose 
were to come forward and deposit these wreaths one after 
another in the following order: 

1. The United Daughters of the Confederacy. 

2. Camp 171. The Confederate Veterans. 

3. Washington Camp No. 305, S. C. V. 

4. State designs, as follows : 

(a) South Carolina. 

(b) Mississippi. 

(c) Florida. 

(d) Alabama. 

(e) Georgia. 

(f) Texas. 

(g) Arkansas. 

(h) North Carolina. 

(i) Tennessee. 

(j) Missouri. 

(k) Kentucky. 

(1) District of Columbia. 

(m) Illinois. 

(n) Philadelphia. 

(o) New York City. 

(p) Maryland. 

(q) Virginia. 

(r) Louisiana. 

(s) Colorado. 

(t) Washington. 

(u) California. 

(v) General Ell Torrance (large floral design). 

A terrific storm, however, now began to burst over the 
grounds. The wreaths, nevertheless, were all deposited, and 
the wreath which had been prepared for the grave where so 
many unknown Union Soldiers are buried, though at some 
distance off", was also placed in spite of the storm by the 
committee appointed for that purpose. 

72 



Reception at the Pan-American Building. 
By night the storm had passed away and the Reception held 
according to program at the beautiful Pan-American build- 
ing was largely attended, and was altogetlier a brilliant affair. 
The receiving party consisted of Mrs. Daisy McLaurin 
Stevens, President General, U. D. C. ; Sir Moses Ezekiel, the 
artist; the Honorable Secretary of State and Mrs. Bryan; Mrs. 
Cornelia Branch Stone, and Mrs. Marion Butler. Mrs. Vir- 
ginia F. McSherry and Colonel Herbert were also to have 
been in the receiving line, but on account of the fatigues of 
the day neither of them was able to attend. The Marine Band 
played, there was dancing, and a handsome supper was served 
in the Fountain Room. 

Conclusion. 

The above is not a stenographic report of the proceedings 
at the unveiling, but the speeches, which were all enthusias- 
tically received by the audience, the order in which they were 
delivered, and the events of the day, are given. 

The purpose was at the conclusion of the ceremonies to 
have the national anthem "America" sung by the whole au- 
dience, the band leading, and to this end printed slips, con- 
taining the words of the song, had been distributed, but the 
storm rendered it impossible to carry out this part of the 
program. 



The following beautiful lines by Mrs. F. P. Hosea, wife 
of Judge Flosea of Cincinnati, Ohio, have been kindly fur- 
nished by the artist, to whom they were written : 

Sir Moses Ezekiel. 

Arlington Monument. 
"Peace ! Divine message to the North ! 
Brought by the glorious Woman, olive-crowned. 
Who, from her war-swept South comes nobly forth 
To plant the olive on her victor's ground. 
Is this the age foretold by Prophet old? 
Her sword is made a plow, her spear 
A sickle, reaping blessings manifold. 
Promised to those who great Jehovah fear. 
She stands majestic 'bove her base, where live 
In speaking bronze her heroes' moving story, 
A woman, not an angel, sent to give 
The message : "Peace on Earth, to God give glory." 
Thus shall thy new South, Ezekiel, ever be 
A symbol of our Southern chivalry ! 

F. P. Hosea. 



m, 








NORTH FRONT. 



CHAPTER V. 
The Monument — What It Means. 

The writer is not an art critic, but for the benefit of the 
thousands who are interested in, but who may never see it, 
and as a help to the many who may hereafter see and not have 
time to examine it carefully, he ventures here a description, the 
result of a careful study he has made of the Confederate 
monument at Arlington. 

The monument with all its figures, plinth, pedestal and all, is 
of bronze. No other monument entirely of bronze, approxi- 
mating this in size, is believed to exist in America, and none has 
been heard of in Europe, except that of Frederick the Great, at 
Berlin. 

The broad base upon which the pedestal of the monument 
stands is of polished granite, some three feet high. The alti- 
tude of the whole structure is 323^4 feet. The thirty-two 
figures around the plinth are all of life-size. Rising in strength 
and beauty above all is the colossal figure of the South. Her 
head is crowned with olive leaves, the emblem of peace. In 
her extended left hand is a wreath of laurel to crown her 
fallen sons, in memory of their heroism ; her strong right hand 
rests upon a plow-stock, on which is a pruning-hook. Under- 
neath is the verse from Isaiah, out of which the artist's con- 
ception grew : "They have beat their swords into plow-shares 
and their spears into pruning-hooks." This means, of course, 
peace between the sections — lasting peace. 

The chief figure, of heroic size, is a woman typifying the 
South. Graciousness seems to be the dominant expression in 
this figure, that stands for the mother of free peoples and their 
statesmen and heroes ; but there is also a tinge of sorrow about 
it, for the figure, before it was m.ounted in its place, brought 
tears to the eyes of beholders. She has survived her struggle 
for constitutional rights, and returns to the pursuits of peace. 



75 



The plinth upon which she stands, adorned with four cinerary 
urns, one for each year of the war, "1861," "1862,'' "1863," 
"1864-5," is supported by a frieze of incHned shields on which 
are the coats of arms of the several Southern States, each 
wrought out in every detail of figure and inscription. The 
support by these State shields of the whole structure upon 
which the figure of the South stands, like every touch of the 
plastic hand of our artist, is full of deep meaning to every one 
who comprehends the history of our country. The States 
seceded as such, and as States they combined to uphold the 
South in her struggle for constitutional right. There are four- 
teen shields on the monument, that of Maryland having been 
added to the thirteen Confederate States, as Maryland troops 
fought gallantly with the seceded States throughout the war. 

The plinth on which the chief figure stands, as appears in 
the photograph, is round. Supported by a rectangular base of 
polished dark gray granite, it stands upon a cylindrical mound 
around which runs a broad circular walk. Around the whole 
plot is a circular carriage drive. Thus all may see the monu- 
ment from all sides, and from every viewpoint it is attractive. 

The dominant figure faces south, that the sun may shine 
upon it from morning till night. That dominant figure is no 
"new South." It is the South that is the mother of Washing- 
ton and Jeft'erson, of Clay and Calhoun, of Jeft'erson Davis 
and Robert E. Lee ; of the heroes, who died for their convic- 
tions from 1861 to 1865, and of the heroes who have survived 
that conflict and who have, since Appomatox, with the imple- 
ments of peace won glorious victories. 

But our sculptor, who is writing history in bronze, also pic- 
tures the South in another attitude, the South as she was in 
1861-1865. For decades she had been contending for her 
constitutional rights, before popular assemblies, in Congress, 
and in the courts. Here in the forefront of the memorial she 
is depicted as a beautiful woman, sinking down almost helpless, 
still holding her shield with "The Constitution" written upon 
it, the full-panoplied Minerva, the Goddess of War and of Wis- 
dom, compassionately vipholding her. In the rear, and beyond 
the mountains, the Spirits of AVar are blowing their trum- 
pets, turning them in every direction to call the sons and 

76 



dang-hters of the South to the aid of their strug-gUng mother. 
The Furies of War also appear in the background, one with 
the terrific hair of a Gorgon, another in funereal drapery up- 
holding a cinerary urn. 

Then the sons and daughters of the South are seen coming 
from every direction. The manner in which they crowd en- 
thusiastically upon each other is one of the most impressive 
features of this colossal work. There they come, represent- 
ing every branch of the service, and in proper garb; soldiers, 
sailors, sappers and miners, all typified. On the right is a 
faithful negro body-servant following his young master, Mr. 
Thomas Nelson Page's realistic "Marse Chan" over again. 
The artist had grown up, like Page, in that embattled old 
Virginia where "Marse Chan" was so often enacted. 

And there is another story told here, illustrating the kindly 
relations that existed all over the South between the master 
and the slave — a story that can not be too often repeated to 
generations in which "Uncle Tom's Cabin" survives and is 
still manufacturing false ideas as to the South and slavery 
in the "fifties." The astonishing fidelity of the slaves ever}^- 
where during the war to the wives and children of those who 
were absent in the army was convincing proof of the kindly 
relations between master and slave in the old South. One 
leading purpose of the U. D. C. is to correct history. Ezekiel 
is here writing it for them, in characters that will tell their 
story to generation after generation. Still to the right of the 
young soldier and his body-servant is an ofificer, kissing his 
child in the arms of an old negro "mammy." Another child 
holds on to the skirts of "mammy" and is crying, perhaps 
without knowing why. 

Then there is the workingman. the blacksmith, with deter- 
mination in his face, trying on his sword, leaving his bellows 
and his workshop, while his wife, with sorrow in her eyes, her 
hand on the an\il, seems to be asking what is to become of her 
and the children. 

There is no allegory in all this, no wings of angels, no 
imaginary beings are anywliere in all the memorial, excepting 
only the classic and familiar ^Minerva and the Ftu-ies ; the 
memorial is a faithful picture of real things — things that 
actuallv happened. 

77 



There is also the clergyman in his robes, his hand resting 
tenderly on the shoulder of his weeping wife, who holds her 
school-boy son's right hand in her own, as he goes off from 
his books and his home to the war. The boy's gun is on his 
shoulder, while his father's hand rests with a blessing on his 
head. This typifies the deep religious feeling that pen^aded 
the Confederate armies, the soldiers, who knelt in prayer and 
rose, musket in hand, to go forward into line of battle. A 
strong oak tree overshadows with its branches at the same 
time the two groups, the preacher and his wife taking leave 
of their schoolboy son, and the blacksmith bidding good-bye to 
his forge and his loved ones. 

Another group is the young bride of war times, her bridal 
gown hooped and flounced as in those days, binding his sword 
and sash around her lover's waist, as he tenderly bends his 
head towards her. 
/, Inscriptions. 

The frontal inscription is the text from Isaiah, out of 
which the conception of the artist grew and which was 
selected by him. "They have beat their swords into plow- 
shares and their spears into pruning-hooks." On another face 
is "To our Dead Heroes — by — The United Daughters of the 
Confederacy." And "Victrix causa Diis placuit, sed victa 
Catoni." 

The other beautiful inscription which is on the Xorth side is : 

Not for fame or reward : 

Not for place or rank : 

Not lured by ambition. 

Or goaded by necessity ; 

But in simple 

Obedience to duty, 

As they understood it. 

These men suffered all. 

Sacrified all, 

Dared all^and died. 

Even this somewhat extended notice is but an outline sketch. 
Every group, every single figure is in itself a study, as is the 
relation of each figure and each group to the whole of this 
wonderful structure. 

78 



Great artists have often, with pencil and with brush, given 
to the world striking pictures of historic happenings as they 
have succeeded each other in human experiences, pictures that 
once seen are never forgotten, such as Hogarth's "Rake's 
Progress'' and some of those period sketches that adorn the 
rotunda of our Capitol. 

But no sculptor, so far as known, has ever, in any one 
memorial told as much history as has Ezekiel in his monument 
at Arlington ; and every human figure in it, as well as every 
symbol, is in and of itself a work of art. 

That monument owes its existence in part to the North, in 
part to the South. In form and substance it came from the 
brain and hand of a great artist whose genius has illuminated 
many of the salons and galleries of the Old World, and has 
adorned many of the great institutions of the New. For 
three years he put his heart, his mind and his soul into it, 
sparing no efifort and no expense ; the Daughters of the Con- 
federacy, through their President-General, turned it over, an 
emblem of a reunited people, into the keeping of the National 
Government, the Government of more than a hundred millions 
of happy and contented people who while these words are 
being written, October, 1914, are enjoying the blessings of 
peace. May that peace last as long as bronze endures or the 
sun shines ! 



79 



LIBRftRY OF CONGRESS 



006 096 486 5 



LIBRARY OF CONGRESS 



006 096 486 5 • 



